Re: [Foundation-l] Lack of research on Wikipedia

2009-08-24 Thread Dennis During
What is most remarkable in many ways is that there has been as much progress on quality and on meeting user needs despite a lack of measurements connected with those. Perhaps that it attributable to the contributor population being a reasonably good match with the user population so that honest co

Re: [Foundation-l] Lack of research on Wikipedia

2009-08-24 Thread Cox, Serita
Awesome :) -Original Message- From: Fowler, John Sent: Monday, August 24, 2009 3:13 PM To: Wikimedia Foundation Mailing List Cc: Lanzerotti, Laura; Cox, Serita Subject: RE: [Foundation-l] Lack of research on Wikipedia Hi all, I stumbled across this thread when I was browsing through so

Re: [Foundation-l] Lack of research on Wikipedia

2009-08-24 Thread Fowler, John
Hi all, I stumbled across this thread when I was browsing through some past foundation-l posts. My name is John Fowler, and I'm with the Bridgespan Group, working with the Wikimedia Foundation during the strategic planning process to develop a fact base to inform future work. We're trying to pull

Re: [Foundation-l] Closure of projects

2009-08-24 Thread Thomas Dalton
2009/8/24 Chad : > I don't know. I don't follow those discussions. I was just clarifying the > question as to "what user roles play into this?" Right now, that only > includes the sysadmins. Implementing the final decision is a job for sysadmins, certainly, but it shouldn't be the sysadmin the mak

Re: [Foundation-l] Closure of projects

2009-08-24 Thread Chad
On Mon, Aug 24, 2009 at 3:59 PM, Thomas Dalton wrote: > 2009/8/24 Chad : >> The only user requirement for this is that a shell user has to >> perform the actual decision. The community makes the decisions >> about opening/closing new projects, and the sysadmins carry >> out the actual task. > > But

Re: [Foundation-l] Closure of projects

2009-08-24 Thread Thomas Dalton
2009/8/24 Chad : > The only user requirement for this is that a shell user has to > perform the actual decision. The community makes the decisions > about opening/closing new projects, and the sysadmins carry > out the actual task. But what is "the community" (the community of the project being cl

Re: [Foundation-l] Closure of projects

2009-08-24 Thread Chad
On Mon, Aug 24, 2009 at 2:14 PM, Andrew Turvey wrote: > First, if the conclusion is that no procedure exists, a notice should be put > on http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Proposals_for_closing_projects stating this > so that peoples' expectations are appropriately managed. > > Second, is that corre

Re: [Foundation-l] Closure of projects

2009-08-24 Thread Andrew Turvey
First, if the conclusion is that no procedure exists, a notice should be put on http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Proposals_for_closing_projects stating this so that peoples' expectations are appropriately managed. Second, is that correct? Looking at http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Proposals_for_c

Re: [Foundation-l] New projects opened

2009-08-24 Thread Gerard Meijssen
Hoi, There are many ways you can approach paid contributions. Saying that it does not work is certainly for localisation manifestly incorrect. The success of the translatewiki.net rally is a case in point. It does work. Now there is a question about WHO is paying for localisations. The team of tra