Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-16 Thread Sergio Costas
Hi all: My two cents: in my opinion, the semi rolling release is a good idea, but not to change the whole base system. Recreating thousands of packages is not a task that can be done in an evening, so I think that Debian should be used as base system. Maybe define a "fixed, non-rolling" base

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-16 Thread Albert Palacios
I like the idea of a "semi" rolling release. Software like "Geary" or "Files" can't be frozen during the whole next cycle, can you imagine not receiving the "search mail" update until Luna+1? Right now I don't feel like Elementary is Beta, yes there are bugs that must be fixed, but it is great to

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-16 Thread Sergio Tortosa Benedito
If we had to change distribution one of the most important to discuss would be which type of packages should be used (rpm, deb ...) and whether we want elementary as rolling release or not. Now my two cents, if I had to choose one package management one option to keep in mind would be pisi, it

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-09 Thread Sergey "Shnatsel" Davidoff
> > ...but it is a good idea to make elementary packages available on as > many platforms as possible. > It gives more publicity and more chances of finding newer developers. > +1 People who are not convinced and want more info on the topic can hit me up for a lecture on "Why it's important to ha

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-09 Thread Manish Sinha
On Tue, Jul 9, 2013 at 11:59 AM, Daniel Foré wrote: > While neither us nor Ubuntu seem to want to align with the full GNOME stack > any longer, we are a little bit closer as far as Gtk/Vala/Mutter/Clutter/etc. Actually elementary is not patching existing gnome components leading to unexpected be

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-09 Thread Daniel Foré
I basically wanted to say what Christian said, but I see your point as well. While neither us nor Ubuntu seem to want to align with the full GNOME stack any longer, we are a little bit closer as far as Gtk/Vala/Mutter/Clutter/etc. There does seem to be some concerns about stuff like SystemD, Way

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-09 Thread Luke Benstead
+1 On 9 Jul 2013 18:09, "Conscious User" wrote: > > Em Ter, 2013-07-09 às 18:42 +0200, Christian Dywan escreveu: > > A GNOME user will say exactly the same about Elementary. Ditching the > > shell, forking the window manager, discarding all apps, adding > Contractor… > > I am a GNOME user, and I

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-09 Thread Conscious User
Em Ter, 2013-07-09 às 18:42 +0200, Christian Dywan escreveu: > A GNOME user will say exactly the same about Elementary. Ditching the > shell, forking the window manager, discarding all apps, adding Contractor… I am a GNOME user, and I can assure you that it's not the same thing. Elementary forks

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-09 Thread Christian Dywan
Am 09.07.2013 11:18, schrieb Sergey "Shnatsel" Davidoff: > I share Conscious User's concerns. In fact, bazaar is in exactly the > same situation now. Canonical has limited resources and they have to > choose where to allocate them. > > Moreover, the status of GNOME stack in Ubuntu repos is already

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-09 Thread Luke Benstead
This is the thread I was referring to where he was discussing bugs and how XMir is a poor approach for an entire desktop: https://plus.sandbox.google.com/115606635748721265446/posts/jdbSVidJyWH My syncing comment was just referring to the fact that as XMir simply houses an X server and directs its

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-09 Thread Chris Timberlake
Yeah, i'm going to bring it up again. Don't kill me. Why not just use something like LibAppImage that handles all the dependencies and produces a distro-independent binary. PPA's are powerful and I understand that, but even with LibAppImage it can take a package from a PPA download any missing dep

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-09 Thread A. "Xylon" V.
+1 Tricking other distros...great idea! :P On Jul 9, 2013 3:23 PM, "Craig" wrote: > +1 > On Jul 9, 2013 12:03 AM, "Conscious User" wrote: > >> >> Erm... I'm not sure how to answer this. None of >> your replies seem to be relevant or even directly >> related to what I said. >> >> >> Em Seg, 2013-

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-09 Thread Craig
+1 On Jul 9, 2013 12:03 AM, "Conscious User" wrote: > > Erm... I'm not sure how to answer this. None of > your replies seem to be relevant or even directly > related to what I said. > > > Em Seg, 2013-07-08 às 23:27 -0500, Cody Garver escreveu: > > If anyone is an opponent of GNOME tech right now

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-09 Thread Pim Vullers
On 09-07-13 11:18, Sergey "Shnatsel" Davidoff wrote: > My idea is to get our packages into all distros we're interested in as > potential base distros by providing packager's documentation (started at > https://docs.google.com/document/d/1PrzhK7j3ljgAeYVgbQtdc7OHdMhjkn5f143XDyUMPDc/edit) > and orga

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-09 Thread Sergey "Shnatsel" Davidoff
I share Conscious User's concerns. In fact, bazaar is in exactly the same situation now. Canonical has limited resources and they have to choose where to allocate them. Moreover, the status of GNOME stack in Ubuntu repos is already daunting. The indicator API split, the online accounts split, the

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-09 Thread Sergey "Shnatsel" Davidoff
Luke Benstead, the info about frame sync issues in XMir is EXACTLY what I feared. Could you post a link to the original post by KWin developer to the thread about Mir? It should be right next to this one. -- Sergey "Shnatsel" Davidoff OS architect @ elementary -- Mailing list: https://launchpad.

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-09 Thread Luke Benstead
People can add PPAs to Debian, but unfortunately Launchpad doesn't support Debian releases as a target[1]. That said, using the Precise target on Stable etc. should work. There are other options though, if Elementary considered Fedora as a base distro (which has an awesome up-to-date GNOME stack),

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-08 Thread Conscious User
But I'm talking about moving away from Ubuntu as a base distro, not moving away from Launchpad. Don't people add PPAs to Debian already? Em Seg, 2013-07-08 às 22:09 -0700, Manish Sinha escreveu: > I do get the gist of what Cody is saying. > > It's basically that the PPA ecosystem has so much p

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-08 Thread Manish Sinha
I do get the gist of what Cody is saying. It's basically that the PPA ecosystem has so much potential and use that any other shortcomings of Ubuntu at the moment is negated just by the PPA ecosystem which makes delivering software to end users a breeze. Personally I would like that elementary is

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-08 Thread Conscious User
Erm... I'm not sure how to answer this. None of your replies seem to be relevant or even directly related to what I said. Em Seg, 2013-07-08 às 23:27 -0500, Cody Garver escreveu: > If anyone is an opponent of GNOME tech right now it's proprietary > video driver developers. Those are concrete iss

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-08 Thread Cody Garver
If anyone is an opponent of GNOME tech right now it's proprietary video driver developers. Those are concrete issues that affect any non-Intel GPU user. I haven't seen any hostility from Ubuntu. On Mon, Jul 8, 2013 at 11:22 PM, Cody Garver wrote: > My sentence ran out of fuel there. PPAs are im

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-08 Thread Cody Garver
My sentence ran out of fuel there. PPAs are immensely valuable and eclipse any popular sentiment right now. On Mon, Jul 8, 2013 at 11:16 PM, Cody Garver wrote: > PPAs. > > > On Mon, Jul 8, 2013 at 11:12 PM, Conscious User > wrote: > >> >> Hi all, >> >> Some time ago, I have noticed that an app

Re: [Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-08 Thread Cody Garver
PPAs. On Mon, Jul 8, 2013 at 11:12 PM, Conscious User wrote: > > Hi all, > > Some time ago, I have noticed that an app I'm developing had > some rendering issues only when the Ubuntu overlay scrollbars > were being used. When I took this to Ubuntu developers, I was > told that my best chance was

[Elementary-dev-community] Moving Away From Ubuntu

2013-07-08 Thread Conscious User
Hi all, Some time ago, I have noticed that an app I'm developing had some rendering issues only when the Ubuntu overlay scrollbars were being used. When I took this to Ubuntu developers, I was told that my best chance was to patch the scrollbars myself because no one was currently working on them