Re: [DNSOP] 5011-security-considerations status

2018-02-01 Thread Wes Hardaker
Michael StJohns writes: > Please, please get rid of activeRefreshOffset, clockskewDriftMargin > and retryDriftMargin.    Replace this with a single paragraph noting > that the maximum time (assuming no retransmissions) a node has to wait > after its holdDownTime expires is activeRefresh.  (e.g. t

Re: [DNSOP] 5011-security-considerations status

2018-02-01 Thread Michael StJohns
*pounds head on table*  I'm really not sure how things get worse each time but they appear to. Please, please get rid of activeRefreshOffset, clockskewDriftMargin and retryDriftMargin.    Replace this with a single paragraph noting that the maximum time (assuming no retransmissions) a node has

[DNSOP] 5011-security-considerations status

2018-02-01 Thread Wes Hardaker
Sorry for the long delay to get this version out (vacation, family issues, deadlines are all just excuses). The -11 version of the document has a redesigned 6.1.6 that I'd love everyone to concentrate on. Hopefully it more clearly articulates the issues surrounding Mike's found need to wait yet