I think people are still reading "deprecated" as "removed". It 100% does
not mean that.
Wouldn't it be more likely that 'old' things are deprecated than new?
What is light about this 100+ message discussion? I myself did not see any
strong arguments against deprecation, which seemed to amount to "m
Not sure what you mean? GraphX is the core Apache Spark technology
underneath GraphFrames - parts of GraphFrames use it. `git grep -i graphx |
wc -l` shows 147 hits for `graphx` in GraphFrames master branch as of now.
I started out getting familiar with the GraphFrames codebase with some low
hangi
I thought that too ... until I read the message from Matei Zaharia:
"Votes to deprecate both SparkR and GraphX have passed. These components
will officially be deprecated in Spark 4."
Didn't know in open source you could deprecate things that have been there
years so lightly without carrying out
So it’s deprecated but I will review some basic graph X PRs as I would like
us to bring graph X back to life — but under our current release structure
we need to deprecate now if we want to be able to remove it in the next few
years.
Twitter: https://twitter.com/holdenkarau
Fight Health Insurance:
I guess you missed where Reynold Xin suggested we instead bring GraphFrames
into Spark and others agreed?
On Tue, Nov 12, 2024 at 12:08 PM Ángel
wrote:
> You only have to look at the subject of this thread of mails. It says
> nothing about graphframes. I thought we were "fighting" against deprec
Nope. didn't miss that, in fact, I mentioned that graphframes used GraphX
under the hood.
The thing is ... even though we were trying to get maintainers the
deprecation of GraphX passed suddenly in the middle of that discussion.
El mar, 12 nov 2024, 21:47, Russell Jurney
escribió:
> I guess you
That is unfortunate. I saw someone volunteer to review my PRs. I thought
there was a holdout?
On Tue, Nov 12, 2024 at 12:56 PM Ángel
wrote:
> Nope. didn't miss that, in fact, I mentioned that graphframes used GraphX
> under the hood.
>
> The thing is ... even though we were trying to get maintai
👍
El mié, 13 nov 2024, 3:52, Holden Karau escribió:
> So it’s deprecated but I will review some basic graph X PRs as I would
> like us to bring graph X back to life — but under our current release
> structure we need to deprecate now if we want to be able to remove it in
> the next few years.
>
Angel, okay, I see the announcement. Thanks for bringing that to my
attention. So, I started out getting up to speed on GraphFrames and doing
a little maintenance. Next I'm going to go in and fix some bugs in GraphX.
On the GraphFrames side, there is actually a bug converting GraphFrames to
GraphX
When you deprecate something, the message you're sending out is: "This
feature is no longer supported, maintained, and recommended for production
use." The problem is that nobody knows how many Spark programs currently
rely on GraphX/Graphframes in production and the impact that decisssion
could ha
ohh.. my fault
https://lists.apache.org/thread/2nd08qpr8nwbtog5bgnpfgkn1r42cd5m
tir. 12. nov. 2024 kl. 20:37 skrev Bjørn Jørgensen :
> "*GraphX have passed*"
>
> @Holden Karau Did it?
>
>
>
> man. 11. nov. 2024 kl. 00:52 skrev Matei Zaharia >:
>
>> It’s time to send out our ASF board report a
"*GraphX have passed*"
@Holden Karau Did it?
man. 11. nov. 2024 kl. 00:52 skrev Matei Zaharia :
> It’s time to send out our ASF board report again this Wednesday. Here is a
> draft — let me know if you have comments or suggestions.
>
> ===
>
> Description:
>
> Apache Spark is a fa
You only have to look at the subject of this thread of mails. It says
nothing about graphframes. I thought we were "fighting" against deprecating
GraphX because it seemed not have any maintainers in quite a few time.
Maybe I got it wrong.
El mar, 12 nov 2024, 19:12, Russell Jurney
escribió:
> No
I think this was all discussed at length.
While Spark of course doesn't collect usage stats, we do have evidence that
was discussed: low commit activity and traffic to this section of the docs.
The argument that it could impact someone doesn't go anywhere - of course
it will impact _someone_. How m
I started working on GraphFrames this weekend, got it building and started
with some docs PRs. A lot of the example code no longer worked, so I fixed
it. I'm updating the docs to indicate our plan to integrate it with Apache
Spark.
I'll announce a hackathon in the next week or so :)
Russell
On W
But the goal wasn't to fix bugs in GraphX? What has that to do with
graphframes?
El mar, 12 nov 2024, 12:58, Russell Jurney
escribió:
> I started working on GraphFrames this weekend, got it building and started
> with some docs PRs. A lot of the example code no longer worked, so I fixed
> it. I'
16 matches
Mail list logo
