Re: [Incubator Ask] Incubator project should learn the Apache Way. Was: Please stop copy code and documentation from ShardingSphere

2022-03-19 Thread Sheng Wu
Hi Yonglun Thanks for the feedback quickly. I would give the space to the community for working this out. On 2022/03/19 09:47:22 Zhang Yonglun wrote: > Hi, > > Thanks to Sheng, Willem and Liang for the guidance. > > I understand Sheng's concern about the agent codes, it's also our > concern. S

Re: [Incubator Ask] Incubator project should learn the Apache Way. Was: Please stop copy code and documentation from ShardingSphere

2022-03-19 Thread Zhang Yonglun
Hi, Thanks to Sheng, Willem and Liang for the guidance. I understand Sheng's concern about the agent codes, it's also our concern. So there has been close discussion within the ShenYu community and with our mentors on this matter. Thanks to Willem for updating the conclusions of ALC Shenzhen tea

Re: [Incubator Ask] Incubator project should learn the Apache Way. Was: Please stop copy code and documentation from ShardingSphere

2022-03-18 Thread Liang Zhang
I agree with Sheng and William deeply. `Community Over Codes` is the best word for Apache Way describing, podlings should not only make the license right. ShenYu copies documents from ShardingSphere's have been for a long time. I reminded ShenYu community once before, but the community only adde

Re: [Incubator Ask] Incubator project should learn the Apache Way. Was: Please stop copy code and documentation from ShardingSphere

2022-03-18 Thread Willem Jiang
I already made a very clear statement in the last ALC Shenzhen team meeting, when ShaoYu brought this kind question up. Please don't copy the code from other projects even if you are the writer, it adds the maintenance burden to your code. BTW, License compliance is the basic rule we need to fol

Re: [Incubator Ask] Incubator project should learn the Apache Way. Was: Please stop copy code and documentation from ShardingSphere

2022-03-18 Thread Sheng Wu
Hi I would like to say great to see you are beginning to re-words these. > After discussing with our mentors, we decided to rewrite these > documentations. I have started a new thread [1] to call for volunteers Notice, PMC should take this responsibility, I don't mean PMC member is not volunte

Re: [Incubator Ask] Incubator project should learn the Apache Way. Was: Please stop copy code and documentation from ShardingSphere

2022-03-18 Thread Zhang Yonglun
Hi Sheng, We appreciate your guidance to the ShenYu community from the perspective of IPMC. After discussing with our mentors, we decided to rewrite these documentations. I have started a new thread [1] to call for volunteers to rewrite the documentations base on how ShenYu as a community is runn

[Incubator Ask] Incubator project should learn the Apache Way. Was: Please stop copy code and documentation from ShardingSphere

2022-03-17 Thread Sheng Wu
Hi Shenyu community I noticed this thread, from the incubator level discussion. The key point of incubating a new project is to teach them to understand and follow the Apache Way and Culture. The document is a reflection of your understanding, right now, there are a lot of documents copying fr

Re: Please stop copy code and documentation from ShardingSphere

2022-03-17 Thread Zhang Yonglun
Hi Liang, Thanks for your feedback. I made fixes [1][2][3] for the docs you pointed out which don't have a license listed. These fixes include adding license and notice of ShardingSphere, and adding a note referencing ShardingSphere to the documentation content. For the agent module, as you men

Please stop copy code and documentation from ShardingSphere

2022-03-16 Thread zhangli...@apache.org
Dear ShenYu community, I noticed that ShenYu agent code and community documentation were copied directly from ShardingSphere. For agent module issue, ShenYu code[1] is almost same as ShardingSphere code[2]. I saw your PR[3], which added ShardingSphere copyright to the LICENSE and NITICE file yest