Re: Migrate from Bugzilla to GitHub Issues

2022-08-18 Thread Dave Fisher
ASF projects must store source and source releases on ASF controlled properties. A significant amount of work has been done in the last decade to connect Gitbox with GitHub. If anyone personally has trouble with Microsoft’s owning GitHub they can use the gitbox mirrors. 14 years ago we had sig

Re: Migrate from Bugzilla to GitHub Issues

2022-08-18 Thread Vladimir Sitnikov
>2. What will happen to the mail list archives with links to Bugzilla ? >Will it possible to redirect Bugzilla urls to the migrated GitHub Issues? I have not explored the possibility to install automatic redirects, however, for JMeter we'll add a comment to every bug that links the corresponding

Re: Migrate from Bugzilla to GitHub Issues

2022-08-18 Thread Yegor Kozlov
GitHub is cool and personally, I much prefer GitHub PRs to Bugzilla. There are two questions though: 1. Github is Apache-friendly, but it is not owned by ASF. For whatever reasons they can change their policy, access, etc. and we won't have control over it. It's hypothetical, but who knows? 2. Wh

Re: Migrate from Bugzilla to GitHub Issues

2022-08-18 Thread Peter Keller
Dear all, When considering a move like this, you might like to also consider alternatives to GitHub. I am not going to argue strongly for one service over another, but just note that there is continuing sensitivity for some over Microsoft's policies with respect to GitHub. The Software Freedo

Re: Migrate from Bugzilla to GitHub Issues

2022-08-18 Thread PJ Fanning
Thanks Vladimir for bringing this up. I think it would be a good idea to have a discussion on this list before anyone dedicates too much effort. My own opinion is that it would be great to get off bugzilla. I see the merit in using Github instead of Jira - because Github is an integrated environ

Re: Migrate from Bugzilla to GitHub Issues

2022-08-18 Thread Vladimir Sitnikov
Just in case, I can prepare a throwaway repository with migrated issues/attachments for POI. I would need an export from Bugzilla database for POI issues. You could ask it from INFRA like in https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/INFRA-23475. >Do you have examples of successful transition from Bugz

Re: Migrate from Bugzilla to GitHub Issues

2022-08-18 Thread Sergey Vladimirov
Hi, Vladimir, Do you have examples of successful transition from Bugzilla to GitHub issues for Apache projects? (already completed ones) Best regards, Sergey Чт, 18 авг. 2022 г. в 08:11, Vladimir Sitnikov : > Hi, > > Have you considered migrating from Bugzilla to GitHub Issues? > > I think co-l

Migrate from Bugzilla to GitHub Issues

2022-08-17 Thread Vladimir Sitnikov
Hi, Have you considered migrating from Bugzilla to GitHub Issues? I think co-locating issues, code, and PRs at GitHub would make it easier to browse both issues and code. I guess many POI users browse code (including POI code) in GitHub, and they would likely use GitHub PRs (POI PRs and PRs for