Re: [DISCUSS] Creating last bug fix release for 1.5 branch

2018-12-14 Thread Maximilian Michels
I have pushed this fix to the release-1.5 branch: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/FLINK-10566 Would be great if we could include it because it has been blocking some pipelines on the Beam side. Thanks, Max On 13.12.18 20:22, Chesnay Schepler wrote: FLINK-11023: will not be fixed for 1.

Re: [DISCUSS] Creating last bug fix release for 1.5 branch

2018-12-13 Thread Chesnay Schepler
FLINK-11023: will not be fixed for 1.5.6; this would take significantly longer to implement, and TBH I'm not really keen on doing that for a final bugfix release. FLINK-7991: This is just a minor cleanup; the issue doesn't affect users in any way. It is thus not particularly important to have fo

Re: [DISCUSS] Creating last bug fix release for 1.5 branch

2018-12-13 Thread Thomas Weise
Hi, I would be interested to try my hand at being the release manger for this. There are currently still 5 in-progress issues [1], all except [2] with an open PR. Nico, Chesnay, Till: Can you please take a look and see if these can be completed? Thanks, Thomas [1] https://issues.apache.org/ji

Re: [DISCUSS] Creating last bug fix release for 1.5 branch

2018-12-10 Thread Thomas Weise
Thanks Till and my belated +1 for a final patch release :) On Mon, Dec 10, 2018 at 5:47 AM Till Rohrmann wrote: > Thanks for the feedback! I conclude that the community is in favour of a > last 1.5.6 release. I'll try to make the arrangements in the next two > weeks. > > Cheers, > Till > > On Mo

Re: [DISCUSS] Creating last bug fix release for 1.5 branch

2018-12-10 Thread Till Rohrmann
Thanks for the feedback! I conclude that the community is in favour of a last 1.5.6 release. I'll try to make the arrangements in the next two weeks. Cheers, Till On Mon, Dec 10, 2018 at 2:40 AM jincheng sun wrote: > +1. There are incompatible improvements between 1.5.x and 1.6/1.7, so many > 1

Re: [DISCUSS] Creating last bug fix release for 1.5 branch

2018-12-09 Thread jincheng sun
+1. There are incompatible improvements between 1.5.x and 1.6/1.7, so many 1.5.x users may not be willing to upgrade to 1.6 or 1.7 due to migration costs, so it makes sense to creating last bug fix release for 1.5 branch. Bests, Jincheng Jeff Zhang 于2018年12月10日周一 上午9:24写道: > +1, I think very fe

Re: [DISCUSS] Creating last bug fix release for 1.5 branch

2018-12-09 Thread Jeff Zhang
+1, I think very few people would use 1.6 or 1.7 in their production in near future, so I expect they would use 1.5 in production for a long period,it makes sense to provide a stable version for production usage. Ufuk Celebi 于2018年12月9日周日 下午6:07写道: > +1. This seems reasonable to me. Since the fi

Re: [DISCUSS] Creating last bug fix release for 1.5 branch

2018-12-09 Thread Ufuk Celebi
+1. This seems reasonable to me. Since the fixes are already in and also part of other releases, the release overhead should be manageable. @Vino: I agree with your assessment. @Qi: As Till mentioned, the official project guideline is to support the last two minor releases, e.g. currently 1.7 and

Re: [DISCUSS] Creating last bug fix release for 1.5 branch

2018-12-08 Thread qi luo
Hi Till, Does Flink has an agreement on how long will a major version be supported? Some companies may need a long time to upgrade Flink major versions in production. If Flink terminates support for a major version too quickly, it may be a concern for companies. Best, Qi > On Dec 8, 2018, at

Re: [DISCUSS] Creating last bug fix release for 1.5 branch

2018-12-07 Thread vino yang
Hi Till, I think it makes sense to release a bug fix version (especially some serious bug fixes) for flink 1.5. Consider that some companies' production environments are more cautious about upgrading large versions. I think some organizations are still using 1.5.x or even 1.4.x. Best, Vino Till

[DISCUSS] Creating last bug fix release for 1.5 branch

2018-12-07 Thread Till Rohrmann
Dear community, I wanted to reach out to you and discuss whether we should release a last bug fix release for the 1.5 branch. Since we have already released Flink 1.7.0, we only need to support the 1.6.x and 1.7.x branches (last two major releases). However, the current release-1.5 branch contain