Re: [ANNOUNCE] Flink 1.20 feature freeze

2024-06-20 Thread Ferenc Csaky
Hi Xintong, Weijie, Thank you both for your answers! Regarding the CLI deprecation process, I agree that it is tricky business, hence I opened this discussion. The proposal makes sense IMO, I will open a discussion thread. With the present timeline, I think it is reasonable to hold it from 1.20,

Re: [ANNOUNCE] Flink 1.20 feature freeze

2024-06-19 Thread weijie guo
+1 for Xintong's point. Hi Ferenc, After discussing this with all the other RM's, we decided not to merge the PR you mentioned into 1.20. The main reason is that FLIP-464 was voted in three days ago, which is already after feature freeze date. It doesn't make sense to us to put it in the 1.20 rel

Re: [ANNOUNCE] Flink 1.20 feature freeze

2024-06-19 Thread Xintong Song
Hi Ferenc, About the deprecation process, removing a @Public API requires the API to be deprecated for at least 2 minor releases AND the removal should be in a major version bump. That means you cannot remove a @Public API in 2.x when x is not 0. The tricky part is, run-application as a command-li

Re: [ANNOUNCE] Flink 1.20 feature freeze

2024-06-18 Thread Ferenc Csaky
Hi Robert, Rui, Ufuk, and Weijie, I would like to raise the PR about merging `flink run` and `flink run-application` functionality [1] to get considered as part of the 1.20 release. The reason IMO is that the `run-application` CLI command should be removed in the same release when Per-Job mode ge

Re: [ANNOUNCE] Flink 1.20 feature freeze

2024-06-18 Thread weijie guo
Hi Zakelly, Thank you for informing us! After discussion, all RMs agreed that this was an important fix that should be merged into 1.20. So feel free to merge it. Best regards, Weijie Zakelly Lan 于2024年6月15日周六 16:29写道: > Hi Robert, Rui, Ufuk and Weijie, > > Thanks for the update! > > FYI:

Re: [ANNOUNCE] Flink 1.20 feature freeze

2024-06-15 Thread Zakelly Lan
Hi Robert, Rui, Ufuk and Weijie, Thanks for the update! FYI: This PR[1] fixes & cleanup the left-over checkpoint directories for file-merging on TM exit. And the second commit fixes the wrong state handle usage. We encountered several unexpected CI fails, so we missed the feature freeze time. It

[ANNOUNCE] Flink 1.20 feature freeze

2024-06-14 Thread weijie guo
Hi everyone, The feature freeze of 1.20 has started now. That means that no new features or improvements should now be merged into the master branch unless you ask the release managers first, which has already been done for PRs, or pending on CI to pass. Bug fixes and documentation PRs can sti