Re: [DISCUSS] Modeling JIRA fix version for subprojects

2024-10-02 Thread Brandon Williams
I think we just need to ask infra to create the jira instances, but I guess we need to have some kind of consistent naming scheme to help identify them? Kind Regards, Brandon On Wed, Oct 2, 2024 at 1:02 PM Francisco Guerrero wrote: > > +1 too on the points brought by Mick, we need more visibilit

Re: Status of CEP-1

2024-10-02 Thread Jon Haddad
> Mostly Analytics, which should not be a blocker for Sidecar. Yes, agreed. I'm just trying to understand the context of the vnode statement and how we're framing 1.0 sidecar. > We definitely need to support 5.0 for the Analytics release, but that's orthogonal to Sidecar. It is, unless we're en

Re: Status of CEP-1

2024-10-02 Thread Francisco Guerrero
> By vnode support, do you mean the analytics library? Or do other features > in sidecar not work with vnodes? Mostly Analytics, which should not be a blocker for Sidecar. However, I do feel there should be more testing around vnodes in Sidecar. > If we're talking about analytics, that gets a li

Re: Status of CEP-1

2024-10-02 Thread Jon Haddad
By vnode support, do you mean the analytics library? Or do other features in sidecar not work with vnodes? If we're talking about analytics, that gets a little complicated. Are we also then talking about 1.0'ing analytics? If so, I think we need support for 5.0 and BTI there. In my opinion, if

Re: [DISCUSS] Modeling JIRA fix version for subprojects

2024-10-02 Thread Francisco Guerrero
+1 too on the points brought by Mick, we need more visibility into subprojects. For starters, we should look into integrating Qbot notifications in #cassandra-dev and #cassandra-noise for CASSANDRASC tickets. Let me know if I can help with that. On 2024/10/02 17:39:28 Yifan Cai wrote: > +1 on all

Re: [DISCUSS] Modeling JIRA fix version for subprojects

2024-10-02 Thread Yifan Cai
+1 on all the points raised by Mick. Please let me know if there is anything I can help with. - Yifan On Wed, Oct 2, 2024 at 8:13 AM Josh McKenzie wrote: > - Qbot notifications in #cassandra-dev and #cassandra-noise , as well as > in any subproject channels > - some cadence of dev@ ML updates,

Re: Status of CEP-1

2024-10-02 Thread Francisco Guerrero
Hi folks, Thanks for all the input. I'm trying to gather all the comments, and from what I can gather it seems that most of the opinions are converging towards scoping a Sidecar release. These are the items that were called out that we will need for a release: - Documentation - Authorization / Aut

Re: Status of CEP-1

2024-10-02 Thread Jon Haddad
When I developed some of the original sidecar code, it was based on REST Easy, which would have allowed us to generate the spec automatically. I did this in a similar project. That was removed here: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CASSANDRASC-57 But unfortunately it looks like you can't ge

Re: Status of CEP-1

2024-10-02 Thread Štefan Miklošovič
Something like this: https://instaclustr.github.io/instaclustr-icarus-go-client/ On Wed, Oct 2, 2024 at 4:54 PM Štefan Miklošovič wrote: > While documenting endpoints please use something like OpenAPI > specification. The sidecar should expose this document itself so when I go > to this and tha

Re: [DISCUSS] Modeling JIRA fix version for subprojects

2024-10-02 Thread Josh McKenzie
> - Qbot notifications in #cassandra-dev and #cassandra-noise , as well as in > any subproject channels > - some cadence of dev@ ML updates, e.g. on activities, or dependency changes, > etc > - regular releases Agree on all 3 points. Also - I've *definitely* fallen off on the project updates for

Re: Status of CEP-1

2024-10-02 Thread Štefan Miklošovič
While documenting endpoints please use something like OpenAPI specification. The sidecar should expose this document itself so when I go to this and that URL, I see all endpoints, I put the payloads / parameters for them and I can just directly call that, no messing with curl / wget or programmatic

Re: Status of CEP-1

2024-10-02 Thread Jon Haddad
Hi Abhijeet, Contributing documentation would be greatly appreciated. Feature wise - is there functionality in sidecar that I missed? What are you finding to be quite useful? I think everyone would benefit to hear from folks who use it and are getting something useful out of it as it will help

Re: Status of CEP-1

2024-10-02 Thread Abhijeet Dubey
Hi folks, I have been using Sidecar recently and have found some of its functionalities to be quite useful. Hari and I are also working on CEP-40 which aims to introduce live migration features in Sidecar in the near future. However, as others have mentioned, I agree that it currently lacks prope

Re: Status of CEP-1

2024-10-02 Thread Štefan Miklošovič
Totally agree with Jon here basically on all fronts. Apache Cassandra Sidecar was always a hard nut to crack for me, that is probably why I have not been involved with that a lot even that is a great tool to have and be invested in as I was writing my own sidecar and I found a lot of similarities a

Re: Status of CEP-1

2024-10-02 Thread Jon Haddad
I don't think we should release sidecar 1.0 without any docs. I took a look through the closed JIRAs to see what's there. Here's what I found, please correct me if there's more: - Lots of stuff related to analytics. I would be pretty excited for this, but the analytics library only works with s