Re: [VOTE][Julia] Release Apache Arrow Julia 2.4.2 RC0

2023-01-14 Thread David Li
+1 (binding) Verified on Ubuntu 18.04/x86_64. -David On Fri, Jan 13, 2023, at 20:16, Sutou Kouhei wrote: > Hi, > > I would like to propose the following release candidate (RC0) of > Apache Arrow Julia version 2.4.2. > > This release candidate is based on commit: > 5ba768918f8088c41e5f89ae8902353

Re: [ANNOUNCE] Apache Arrow ADBC 0.1.0 Released

2023-01-14 Thread David Li
Thanks Andrew! Several people helped, particularly Kou, Matt, and Jacob, and this release also builds heavily on the nanoarrow project that Dewey is spearheading. I know Rust was neglected for this initial push, but I would like to get around to that someday. (If you're interested, feel free to

Re: [Monorepo] Add labels breaking-change and critical-fix

2023-01-14 Thread Antoine Pitrou
I'm quite skeptical about this. My experience is that many people have a very subjective idea of what is critical or not, and the categorization ends up not very informative. Regards Antoine. Le 13/01/2023 à 23:53, Will Jones a écrit : Following up: I have created a PR adding the definit

Re: [VOTE][Julia] Release Apache Arrow Julia 2.4.2 RC0

2023-01-14 Thread Jacob Quinn
+1 (binding) Verified on MacOS m1. -Jacob On Fri, Jan 13, 2023 at 6:17 PM Sutou Kouhei wrote: > Hi, > > I would like to propose the following release candidate (RC0) of > Apache Arrow Julia version 2.4.2. > > This release candidate is based on commit: > 5ba768918f8088c41e5f89ae890235354a887fd6

Re: [Monorepo] Add labels breaking-change and critical-fix

2023-01-14 Thread Will Jones
> > I'm quite skeptical about this. My experience is that many people have a > very subjective idea of what is critical or not, and the categorization > ends up not very informative. Antoine, skeptical about the definition of "Critical Fix"? Or something else? On "Critical Fix", I tried to make t

Re: [Monorepo] Add labels breaking-change and critical-fix

2023-01-14 Thread Antoine Pitrou
Hi Will, Le 14/01/2023 à 17:06, Will Jones a écrit : I'm quite skeptical about this. My experience is that many people have a very subjective idea of what is critical or not, and the categorization ends up not very informative. Antoine, skeptical about the definition of "Critical Fix"? Or s

Re: [Monorepo] Add labels breaking-change and critical-fix

2023-01-14 Thread Weston Pace
On further thought it seems a little odd to me that crashes are not critical. However, many of our crashes are from a failure to properly validate user input, which I agree isn't as critical. Would it be too nuanced to say that: * A crash, given valid input, is critical * A crash, given invali

Re: [Monorepo] Add labels breaking-change and critical-fix

2023-01-14 Thread Antoine Pitrou
A crash on invalid *user* input can easily turn into a security vulnerability (if only because it's a possible vector for DoS attacks), and so should definitely be considered critical. What's not critical is a crash when the caller of a C++ API doesn't respect the API contract (e.g. passes

Re: [VOTE][Julia] Release Apache Arrow Julia 2.4.2 RC0

2023-01-14 Thread Sutou Kouhei
+1 I ran the following command line: VERIFY_FORCE_USE_JULIA_BINARY=1 dev/release/verify_rc.sh 2.4.2 0 Thanks, -- kou In <20230114.101652.873404987541303160@clear-code.com> "[VOTE][Julia] Release Apache Arrow Julia 2.4.2 RC0" on Sat, 14 Jan 2023 10:16:52 +0900 (JST), Sutou Kouhei w

[RESULT][VOTE][Julia] Release Apache Arrow Julia 2.4.2 RC0

2023-01-14 Thread Sutou Kouhei
Hi, The vote carries with 3 +1 binding votes and no -1 votes. I'll publish this release to https://dist.apache.org/repos/dist/release/arrow/ . Thanks, -- kou In <20230114.101652.873404987541303160@clear-code.com> "[VOTE][Julia] Release Apache Arrow Julia 2.4.2 RC0" on Sat, 14 Jan 2023 1