Re: Desert island test

2008-03-11 Thread MJ Ray
Anthony Towns <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: [...] > No, a license that doesn't follow the DFSG is non-free; a license that > fails the dissident test is merely not useful for someone who wants to > violate local law while obeying copyright law. > > The claim that protesting is a "field of endeavour",

Re: Desert island test

2008-03-11 Thread Miriam Ruiz
2008/3/11, MJ Ray <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > Why describe the dissident test as relying solely on the "field of > endeavour" (DFSG 6) guideline? That's new and also seems like a strawman: > I think that it's clear that protesting is a field, but I don't think > identity-disclosure necessarily prev

Do web applications disable GPL obligations?

2008-03-11 Thread Mark Tyler
Dear all, I hope this is the right list to discuss GPL related issues. (Or where would be a better place to get help with the following question?) A friend and I have developed a web application for an online shop with some pretty advanced features that were requested by our customers. We includ

Re: Do web applications disable GPL obligations?

2008-03-11 Thread Måns Rullgård
Mark Tyler <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > Dear all, > I hope this is the right list to discuss GPL related issues. (Or where > would be a better place to get help with the following question?) Your question doesn't relate to Debian, so strictly speaking it is off-topic here. > A friend and I have

k3b monkey audio plugin

2008-03-11 Thread Robin Heron
Hi, I am unclear of the license and exactly which section a deb package should belong. I am currently building k3b plugin for monkeys audio codec. The author has licenced under GPL 2 so no problem there. The actual codec however uses the following: Monkey's Audio Source Code Lice

Re: k3b monkey audio plugin

2008-03-11 Thread Måns Rullgård
Robin Heron <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > Hi, >I am unclear of the license and exactly which section a deb package > should belong. I am currently building k3b plugin for monkeys audio > codec. The author has licenced under GPL 2 so no problem there. > The actual codec however uses the follow

Re: Do web applications disable GPL obligations?

2008-03-11 Thread Matthew Johnson
On Tue Mar 11 16:14, Mark Tyler wrote: > A friend and I have developed a web application for an online shop > with some pretty advanced features that were requested by our > customers. We included GPL sources into the application and for that > reason distributed the application according to the sa