Re: Converting Windows RC to NIBs (was Re: Creating and App menu from Scratch)

2008-07-28 Thread Jonathan Hess
On Jul 16, 2008, at 3:38 AM, Uli Kusterer wrote: On 14.07.2008, at 14:53, Bill Royds wrote: Are there any good tools for porting Application menus and forms from other windowing systems (such as MS Windows or X or even Carbon) to Cocoa nibs? I have a number of applications that I would li

Converting Windows RC to NIBs (was Re: Creating and App menu from Scratch)

2008-07-16 Thread Uli Kusterer
On 14.07.2008, at 14:53, Bill Royds wrote: Are there any good tools for porting Application menus and forms from other windowing systems (such as MS Windows or X or even Carbon) to Cocoa nibs? I have a number of applications that I would like to port, but redesigning the form or menu layout

Re: Creating and App menu from Scratch

2008-07-14 Thread Bill Royds
On 14-Jul-08, at 17:55 , Kyle Sluder wrote: I suppose the question I should be asking you is, who is your audience? What does your product do? Why do you want to auto-generate your user interface in a serialized object graph form from a textual template? That certainly wouldn't be my first c

Re: Creating and App menu from Scratch

2008-07-14 Thread Georg Seifert
Hello, I hope this is appropriate on this this list: As the discussion goes around Interface design, would it be for any interest for developers with no time or experience in interface design if I offer my services? I’m a graphic designer with focus on interface design. And I’m programmin

Re: Creating and App menu from Scratch

2008-07-14 Thread Kyle Sluder
On Mon, Jul 14, 2008 at 3:06 PM, Bill Royds <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Forms layout is not part of the "standard user experience" in general, > although forms look and feel is. Wrong. Otherwise the Apple HIG, the Windows interface guidelines, the Gnome HIG, etc. all would lack sections on the p

Re: Creating and App menu from Scratch

2008-07-14 Thread Bill Royds
On 14-Jul-08, at 12:38 , Gregory Weston <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>wrote: No he's not. Long-time Mac developers know quite well that by and large Mac users are very averse to apps that simply don't fit. It's not a question of arguments about "better" or "worse" (although such arguments can cert

Re: Creating and App menu from Scratch

2008-07-14 Thread Gregory Weston
Kyle Sluder wrote: On Mon, Jul 14, 2008 at 9:37 AM, Bill Royds <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: The layout may be a "standard" form required by law or other convention. I am not suggesting that one port the code, just the forms and menu labels. I know of no statute that mandates Look & Feel, an

Re: Creating and App menu from Scratch

2008-07-14 Thread Gregory Weston
Bill Royds wrote: On 14-Jul-08, at 09:20 , Kyle Sluder wrote: It would lead to a large increase in poorly-designed, auto-ported Mac applications. And then developers would wonder why nobody wants to purchase their software, even though the Windows version did so well. Not necessarily. You a

Re: Creating and App menu from Scratch

2008-07-14 Thread Kyle Sluder
On Mon, Jul 14, 2008 at 9:37 AM, Bill Royds <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Not necessarily. You are assuming that all other interfaces are inferior to > Macintosh interfaces. No, I am asserting that not following the conventions established on the Mac is inferior to following those conventions, rega

Re: Creating and App menu from Scratch

2008-07-14 Thread Bill Royds
On 14-Jul-08, at 09:20 , Kyle Sluder wrote: It would lead to a large increase in poorly-designed, auto-ported Mac applications. And then developers would wonder why nobody wants to purchase their software, even though the Windows version did so well. Not necessarily. You are assuming that al

Re: Creating and App menu from Scratch

2008-07-14 Thread Kevin Walzer
Bill Royds wrote: Are there any good tools for porting Application menus and forms from other windowing systems (such as MS Windows or X or even Carbon) to Cocoa nibs? I have a number of applications that I would like to port, but redesigning the form or menu layout completely seems to be ra

Re: Creating and App menu from Scratch

2008-07-14 Thread Kyle Sluder
On Mon, Jul 14, 2008 at 8:53 AM, Bill Royds <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Being able to do this would lead to an large increase in the number of > Macintosh applications available. It would lead to a large increase in poorly-designed, auto-ported Mac applications. And then developers would wonder

Re: Creating and App menu from Scratch

2008-07-14 Thread Bill Royds
On 14-Jul-08, at 01:38 , Bill Bumgarner <[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Your application's menu isn't that big of a deal, but your application's integration with Mac OS X is a very big deal and that is most of the battle of doing "nib less" development. It is much more than just populating the