Re: [ceph-users] НА: Different filesystems on OSD hosts at the samecluster

2015-08-07 Thread Udo Lembke
Hi, I think also it's much too complicate and the effort is not in any relation, like Megor allready wrote the osd-journal on SSD handle the speed. But for the persistant device names you can easily use partlabel and select the disk with something like /dev/disk/by-partlabel/ext4-journal-15 I d

Re: [ceph-users] НА: Different filesystems on OSD hosts at the samecluster

2015-08-07 Thread Jan Schermer
An interesting benchmark would be to compare "Ceph SSD journal" + "ext4 on spinner" versus "Ceph without journal" + "ext4 on spinner with external SSD journal". I won't be surprised if the second outperformed the first - you are actually making the whole setup much simpler and Ceph is mostly CPU

[ceph-users] НА: Different filesystems on OSD hosts at the samecluster

2015-08-07 Thread Межов Игорь Александрович
Hi! >No, I was indeed talking about the ext4 journals, e.g. described here: ... >but the problem with the persistent device names is keeping me from trying it. So you assume 3-way setup in Ceph: first drive for filesystem data, second drive for filesystem journal and third drive for ceph journal?