[ceph-users] Re: some ceph general questions about the design

2020-04-21 Thread Antoine Lecrux
ri Sent: Tuesday, April 21, 2020 2:59 AM To: ceph-users Subject: [ceph-users] Re: some ceph general questions about the design > > 1. shoud i use a raid controller a create for example a raid 5 with all disks > on each osd server? or should i passtrough all disks to ceph osd? > &

[ceph-users] Re: some ceph general questions about the design

2020-04-21 Thread Anthony D'Atri
> > 1. shoud i use a raid controller a create for example a raid 5 with all disks > on each osd server? or should i passtrough all disks to ceph osd? > > If your OSD servers have HDDs, buy a good RAID Controller with a > battery-backed write cache and configure it using multiple RAID-0 volume

[ceph-users] Re: some ceph general questions about the design

2020-04-20 Thread Khodayar Doustar
Hi Harald, - then i build a 3 node osd cluster and passtrough all disks and i install the mgr daemon on them - i build 3 seperate mon server and install here the rgw? right? As other friends suggested you can use VMs for mgr, mon and rgw, they are not so IOPS intensive and they are very flexible

[ceph-users] Re: some ceph general questions about the design

2020-04-20 Thread Antoine Lecrux
Hi Harald, 1. shoud i use a raid controller a create for example a raid 5 with all disks on each osd server? or should i passtrough all disks to ceph osd? If your OSD servers only contain flash drives, I'd suggest you go with a cheap HBA and configure it in JBOD mode (pass-though) If your OSD se

[ceph-users] Re: some ceph general questions about the design

2020-04-20 Thread harald . freidhof
ok thx for the answers we will connect later nearly 20 kvm hosts on the ceph cluster - then i build a 3 node osd cluster and passtrough all disks and i install the mgr daemon on them - i build 3 seperate mon server and install here the rgw? right? a few question to the options: - osd crush cho

[ceph-users] Re: some ceph general questions about the design

2020-04-20 Thread Phil Regnauld
harald.freid...@gmail.com (harald.freidhof) writes: > > 1. shoud i use a raid controller a create for example a raid 5 with all disks > on each osd server? or should i passtrough all disks to ceph osd? Set up the raid controller in JBOD mode, and passthrough the disks. > 2. if i have a

[ceph-users] Re: some ceph general questions about the design

2020-04-20 Thread Freddy Andersen
1. Do not use raid for osd disks... 1 ods per disk 2-3. I would have 3 or more osd nodes... more is better for when you have issues or need maintenance. We use vms for mon nodes with mgr on each mon node. 5 is the recommended for a production cluster but you can be ok with 3 for a small cluster