Re: idea for a universal disk interface

2022-04-17 Thread shadoooo via cctalk
Hello Paul, using analog signal is not in my intentions, because usually you don't have access to analog signals on disk interface. For some media, e.g. floppy and MFM, you don't have a clock reference on the interface, so you need to detect magnetic pulses and then reconstruct data from timing.

Re: idea for a universal disk interface

2022-04-17 Thread Guy Sotomayor via cctalk
I have proceeded as far as full block diagrams (still have to write all of the verilog) and basic SW architecture.  This is why I've had this discussion.  I've thought about this *a lot* and have gone through several iterations of what will or will not work given timing constraints. I have all

Re: idea for a universal disk interface

2022-04-17 Thread Guy Sotomayor via cctalk
I chose ESDI and SMD fundamentally because the interface is 100% digital (e.g. the data/clock separator is in the drive itself). So I don't need to do any oversampling. TTFN - Guy On 4/17/22 11:12, Paul Koning via cctalk wrote: On Apr 17, 2022, at 1:28 PM, shad via cctalk wrote: hello

Re: idea for a universal disk interface

2022-04-17 Thread Paul Koning via cctalk
> On Apr 17, 2022, at 1:28 PM, shad via cctalk > wrote: > > hello, > there's much discussion about the right method to transfer data in and out. > Of course there are several methods, the right one must be carefully chosen > after some review of all the disk interfaces that must be supp

Re: idea for a universal disk interface

2022-04-17 Thread shadoooo via cctalk
hello, there's much discussion about the right  method to transfer data in and out. Of course there are several methods, the right one must be carefully chosen after some review of all the disk interfaces that must be supported. The idea of having a copy of the whole disk in RAM is OK, assuming t