Dear Flemming,
On 8/21/19, Flemming Goery wrote:
> I find the message in my original e-mail has changed, perhaps by hackers,
What do u mean by 'hackers' BTW!!!
>
> Dear all:
> A has sought a job in the lab of B. B invited A for a interview with a PPT
> oral presentation, as requested A has sen
__
发件人: Nagarajan V
发送时间: 2019年8月21日 21:17
收件人: Flemming Goery
主题: Re: [ccp4bb] not solely pdb issue: need someone to officially settle the
pdb dispute
Speaking somewhat from experience, C’s stance is more common. A can write to
B’s funding agency or initiate action thru official chann
] Re: [ccp4bb] not solely pdb issue: need someone to
officially settle the pdb dispute
EXTERNAL : Real sender is owner-ccp...@jiscmail.ac.uk
Another problem is that the structure was apparently originally not cited
properly, and now still cited as work from the lab of B, rather than as work of
A
Another problem is that the structure was apparently originally not cited
properly, and now still cited as work from the lab of B, rather than as work of
A...
Mark J van Raaij
Dpto de Estructura de Macromoleculas
Centro Nacional de Biotecnologia - CSIC
calle Darwin 3
E-28049 Madrid, Spain
tel. (
From the story, it seems to be a bit more complicated than that, using not only
a deposited public-domain PDB, but also other data transferred confidentially
(undeposited pdb and oral and written reports). This does seem unethical to me.
I have to admit we only have one side of the story though.
If the structure has been deposited in the PDB and thus is public ally
available, B (or F, G, Φ, Ξ, Δ, Α or whoever else) has every right to use it in
a publication.
“A” should follow the advice of Frank and do a happy dance for the usefulness
of the work, or if not feeling like dancing she/he
If A had deposited it to the PDB immediately, he'd have had been able to claim
the kudos and help lots of scientists besides B.
How is it that we structural biologists still are so precious about our
coordinates? Or more to the point, that the supervisors still don't teach
their students that
Dear all:
A has sought a job in the lab of B. B invited A for a interview with a PPT oral
presentation, as requested B has sent the PPT on the structural biology
research of XXX to B by e-mail, and presented in front of A and his
postdoctoral researcher.
After interview, B requested all researc
