Re: DIS: proto: renumeration

2007-06-19 Thread Michael Slone
On 6/19/07, Ed Murphy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Never mind all the rules that carry out mathematics without using "number", in which case R1023(a) may not apply anyway. I suggest amending it to "All mathematics is restricted to real numbers unless explicitly specified otherwise". You mean `

Re: DIS: proto: renumeration

2007-06-19 Thread Zefram
Ed Murphy wrote: >Rule 2136 (Contests) does not explicitly specify that scores are >real, not to mention whatever future rules might be adopted. Score is the "number of points possessed". To me this is inherently a real number. If we defined points to be quanta then score would be inherently int

Re: DIS: proto: renumeration

2007-06-19 Thread Ed Murphy
Zefram wrote: Amend rule 1023 by deleting the item (a) The term "number" shall mean "real number". [Each instance of "number" in the ruleset either is discussing a value that is inherently a natural number or is explicitly qualified as "rational" or some other subset of the real numbers.

DIS: proto: renumeration

2007-06-19 Thread Zefram
proto-proposal: renumeration AI: 2 {{{ Amend rule 1023 by deleting the item (a) The term "number" shall mean "real number". [Each instance of "number" in the ruleset either is discussing a value that is inherently a natural number or is explicitly qualified as "rational" or some other sub