Zefram wrote:

Amend rule 1023 by deleting the item

      (a) The term "number" shall mean "real number".

[Each instance of "number" in the ruleset either is discussing a value
that is inherently a natural number or is explicitly qualified as
"rational" or some other subset of the real numbers.]

Rule 2136 (Contests) does not explicitly specify that scores are
real, not to mention whatever future rules might be adopted.

Here are all the ruleset's uses of "number":

  * Power (non-negative rational, R1688)
  * Rule number (natural, R2141)
  * Index (extended real, R2146)
  * Number of ballots (presumably natural, but what happens when
      Quazie attempts to vote 2+3i x FOR? R683)
  * Number of voters who voted (inherently natural, R955)
  * Quorum (inherently natural, R879)
  * Number of eligible voters (inherently natural, R2019)
  * Length of sentence (1*Power or 2*Power, R1504)
  * Score (unspecified, R2136)

Never mind all the rules that carry out mathematics without using
"number", in which case R1023(a) may not apply anyway.  I suggest
amending it to "All mathematics is restricted to real numbers
unless explicitly specified otherwise".

Reply via email to