DIS: Re: BUS: Notary's notes on proposals 5842-5941

2008-11-15 Thread Taral
On Sat, Nov 15, 2008 at 8:11 AM, Alex Smith <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > P9 is the only contract which has a chance of becoming a contest; the > other 99 proposals are not powerful enough to override rule 2136b and > cause comex to be contestmaster of more than one contest at once. Even if they we

DIS: Re: BUS: Notary's notes on proposals 5842-5941

2008-11-15 Thread Ed Murphy
ais523 wrote: > I call for judgement on the statement "P9 is a contest". > > Arguments: > comex never explicitly consented to be contestmaster of P9, thus > proposal 5842 had no effect (despite passing) because it is > insufficiently powerful to override rule 2136a. Gratuituous counterargument: