Re: DIS: New Proto with different judgements

2008-02-22 Thread Zefram
Roger Hicks wrote: >What permits the BobTHJ-in-Vote-Market position to deregister? Its playerhood, which is tied to the BobTHJ aspect. -zefram

Re: DIS: New Proto with different judgements

2008-02-21 Thread Kerim Aydin
On Thu, 21 Feb 2008, Ben Caplan wrote: > We have here a moral, not a factual, decision. Either choice makes sense; > which one is _right_? The general practice is that if two decisions are equally, or close to similarly "reasonable", then we defer to the judge's call. That is, a hypothetical App

Re: DIS: New Proto with different judgements

2008-02-21 Thread Roger Hicks
On Thu, Feb 21, 2008 at 3:52 PM, Ben Caplan <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > If the agent of Registrar (through Cantus Cygneus) doesn't > > >satisfy, neither would the agent of a deputy. > > > > Nice point. Its validity comes down to the question of how much > > BobTHJness is e

Re: DIS: New Proto with different judgements

2008-02-21 Thread Ben Caplan
> > If the agent of Registrar (through Cantus Cygneus) doesn't > >satisfy, neither would the agent of a deputy. > > Nice point. Its validity comes down to the question of how much > BobTHJness is entailed in the position that I was deputising for. > As noted above, I think there wa

Re: DIS: New Proto with different judgements

2008-02-21 Thread Zefram
Kerim Aydin wrote: >> == CFJ 1895 == >>BobTHJ is an R2160 'position' ... >This Court finds FALSE. Good analysis. >> == CFJ 1899 == >>BobTHJ CAN register. ... >First, I offer

Re: DIS: New Proto with different judgements

2008-02-21 Thread Geoffrey Spear
On Thu, Feb 21, 2008 at 3:39 PM, Kerim Aydin <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > A set of proto-judgements... I suggest you resubmit the first as a thesis for a D.N.Phil.

DIS: New Proto with different judgements

2008-02-21 Thread Kerim Aydin
[I have substantially changed my opinion as a result of the recent conversations] A set of proto-judgements... On Mon, 18 Feb 2008, Ed Murphy wrote: > == CFJ 1895 == >BobTHJ is an R2160 'position' Agora, by long tradition, is fundam