Re: Alternative to Frescobaldi
Am So., 4. Sept. 2022 um 08:51 Uhr schrieb Silvain Dupertuis : > > As far as editing music sheet is concerned,Io remember having been using > jEdit, a text editor written in Java, with a Lilypond extension displaying > the PDF with links to the Lilypond code like Frescobaldi does it. > > That was a long time ago, maybe before I even had Frescobaldi, but it would > be worthwhile exploring... > > Silvain Dupertuis I'm still using jEdit, though the LilyPondTool plugin is not maintained for a decade: http://lilypondtool.blogspot.com/2012/09/lilypondtool-2149-release-last-for.html Personally I don't care about it, though therefore I'd not recommend jEdit for starters. Cheers, Harm
Re: Alternative to Frescobaldi
How about Elysium? http://elysium.thsoft.hu/getting-started I have never tried it, but it is suggested on the Lilypond website: http://lilypond.org/easier-editing.html On Sun, 4 Sep 2022, 17:52 Thomas Morley, wrote: > Am So., 4. Sept. 2022 um 08:51 Uhr schrieb Silvain Dupertuis > : > > > > As far as editing music sheet is concerned,Io remember having been using > jEdit, a text editor written in Java, with a Lilypond extension displaying > the PDF with links to the Lilypond code like Frescobaldi does it. > > > > That was a long time ago, maybe before I even had Frescobaldi, but it > would be worthwhile exploring... > > > > Silvain Dupertuis > > I'm still using jEdit, though the LilyPondTool plugin is not > maintained for a decade: > > http://lilypondtool.blogspot.com/2012/09/lilypondtool-2149-release-last-for.html > > Personally I don't care about it, though therefore I'd not recommend > jEdit for starters. > > Cheers, > Harm > >
tremolo w/dots
Does LilyPond know how to do this without resorting to using \markup? The
dots over the stemDown note also looks too far right. I could adjust it on a
case-by-case basis but that seems rather tedious if LilyPond can do the dots
itself without using \markup.
-David
\version "2.22.2"
\relative c' {
\time 2/4
\repeat tremolo 4 { c16^\markup{ ""}}
\repeat tremolo 4 { c'16^\markup{ ""}}
}
Re: tremolo w/dots
Am So., 4. Sept. 2022 um 15:46 Uhr schrieb bobr...@centrum.is
:
>
> Does LilyPond know how to do this without resorting to using \markup? The
> dots over the stemDown note also looks too far right. I could adjust it on a
> case-by-case basis but that seems rather tedious if LilyPond can do the dots
> itself without using \markup.
>
> -David
>
> \version "2.22.2"
>
> \relative c' {
> \time 2/4
> \repeat tremolo 4 { c16^\markup{ ""}}
> \repeat tremolo 4 { c'16^\markup{ ""}}
> }
>
https://lsr.di.unimi.it/LSR/Item?id=772
Cheers,
Harm
Re: Alternative to Frescobaldi
TL;DR You need to follow Usage, §4.1.1 for evince to call lilypond-invoke-editor successfully. On Sat 03 Sep 2022 at 08:49:11 (+0100), J Martin Rushton wrote: > On Fri, 2022-09-02 at 19:53 -0500, David Wright wrote: > > On Fri 02 Sep 2022 at 22:46:01 (+0100), J Martin Rushton wrote: > > > On Fri, 2022-09-02 at 16:17 -0500, David Wright wrote: > > > > On Fri 02 Sep 2022 at 21:43:25 (+0100), J Martin Rushton wrote: > > > > > I've just spent another couple of hours clearing out previous > > > > > attempts > > > > > to get Frescobaldi running and attempting to sort out its > > > > > dependency > > > > > hell. > > > > > > > > > > Is there any alternative to Frescobaldi? > > > > > > > > An editor (emacs) + LilyPond + PDF viewer (xpdf). > > > > (My choices in parentheses.) > > > > > > > > > I'm running AlmaLinux 8.6 if that helps. > > > > > > > > Not a great deal; does it mean that F~ isn't part of the > > > > distribution? > > > > > > > My preference is for vi, but yes, that's what I've been using for > > > the > > > last couple of years since F~ stopped working. What I miss though > > > is > > > the back link from the score to the source, and the MIDI playback. > > > > 0. Which PDF viewer, and which version of LP? > > Evince > $ lilypond -v > GNU LilyPond 2.22.1 > ... > > > > > 1. Does the PDF have the textedit URLs? > >$ grep -a textedit foo.pdf > >/URI(textedit:///tmp/restpos.ly:4:16:17)>> > > ……… > > Yes > > > 2. Does the PDF viewer see them? Look for cursor to change as you > >move over a notehead. > > Yes > > > 3. Run the PDF viewer from the commandline. Click on an active > >notehead. What appears on the console? Anything like: > > lilypond-invoke-editor (GNU LilyPond) 2.22.0 > > "textedit:///BlowAwayTheMorningDew.ly:35:16:17" Is than on the console, or in the evince window itself? Because I don't use evince, and haven't set it up, I get "Unable to open external link". But your message starts with "textedit" rather than "lilypond-invoke-editor", which might be a similar problem. I think you need to set up the GNOME section in Usage §4.1.1. Whether you also need the following section, "Extra configuration for Evince", depends on whether Alma has configured apparmor or not. Repost if you get permission errors. > > 4. Is lilypond-invoke-editor defined? > >$ which lilypond-invoke-editor > >/usr/bin/lilypond-invoke-editor > > $ command -v lilypond > /opt/bin/lilypond > $ ls -l /opt/bin/lilypond > -rwxr-xr-x 1 root root 112 Feb 13 2022 /opt/bin/lilypond > $ ls -l /opt/bin/lilypond-invoke-editor > lrwxrwxrwx 1 root root 31 Feb 13 2022 /opt/bin/lilypond-invoke-editor > -> /opt/bin/lilypond-wrapper.guile > > > > 5. Can lilypond-invoke-editor open a file in an editor, > >preferably the one you want? > >$ lilypond-invoke-editor textedit:///tmp/foo.txt:2:4:6 > >/tmp/foo.txt is the full path to any old text file with > >more than a couple of lines in it. The cursor should land > >on the second line, four chars along. > > $ lilypond-invoke-editor > textedit:BlowAwayTheMorningDew.ly:2:4:6 > lilypond-invoke-editor (GNU LilyPond) 2.22.1 > sh: emacsclient: command not found > sh: emacs: command not found 5a. Try: $ LYEDITOR=gvim lilypond-invoke-editor textedit:BlowAwayTheMorningDew.ly:2:4:6 If that works, you need to set LYEDITOR in your startup file. That might be as above or, in view of your answer below, to: LYEDITOR="vi --servername gvim" Or start editing with: $ vi --servername gvim BlowAwayTheMorningDew.ly If vi isn't running when you point and click, you should just get an extra message, like 'E247: no registered server named "GVIM": Send failed. Trying to execute locally', which should be harmless. (The benefit of starting vi yourself is that you get to control where it runs, rather than it just popping up when you click the first time.) If 5a doesn't work, substitute EDITOR for LYEDITOR. (The benefit of LYEDITOR is that EDITOR usually has a meaning across the entire OS, rather than just this application.) > > How many of those steps work? > > > > And at the other end of the process, are you starting vi as > > a server, with something like: > > > > $ gvim > > $ vim --servername GVIM > > $ vi --servername gvim > > > > (letter-case unimportant), else you might see: > > E247: no registered server named "GVIM": Send failed. > > $ vi BlowAwayTheMorningDew.ly > > FYI > $ command -v vi > /usr/bin/vi > bash-4.4$ ls -l /usr/bin/vi > -rwxr-xr-x 1 root root 1180368 Aug 2 17:57 /usr/bin/vi Cheers, David.
Re: Create 16th-century microtonal accidental
Thank you for these thoughts. I'm aware of the Helmholtz-Ellis notation and decided not to use it (or any other contemporary approach to microtonality). My thesis is that Vicentino's notation is in fact a tabulature for his Archicembalo / Arciorgano (keyboard instruments with up to 36 keys per octave), so they are a reference to a location on the keyboard, not to a specific pitch (be it relative or absolute). Since the tuning of those instruments is context-dependent it would be confusing to define the 'meaning' of the notation in terms of exact interval sizes. I'm happy to discuss this further in case you are interested, but maybe we better do that off the lilypond-list. Hans Åberg writes: >> On 2 Sep 2022, at 10:24, Johannes Keller wrote: >> >> I would like to use Lilypond for a critical edition of Nicola >> Vicentino's treatise "L'antica musica" (Rome 1555). The original >> notation uses an unconventional accidental to indicate a pitch >> modification of a "Diesis" (ca. 1/5 of a whole tone). > … >> Examples of the original notation can be found here, see for example >> fol. 12v (PDF p. 24): >> >> http://vmirror.imslp.org/files/imglnks/usimg/9/94/IMSLP114662-PMLP210243-lantica_musica.pdf > > In case you would want to translate into modern microtonal notation: > > The enharmonic diesis 128/125, the difference between an octave 2 and > three Just Intonation major thirds 5/4, is actually an interval of > relative scale degree 1, not an accidental, or an interval of relative > scale degree 0. > > So this means that if this old manuscript, where the enharmonic diesis > is written as an accidental, is translated into modern Helmholtz-Ellis > notation, the note ends on the position one above in the staff > notation, with a triple raised syntonic comma 81/80, combined with > some other accidental like a flat or double flat.
Re: Create 16th-century microtonal accidental
The Harvard Concise says that in the 15th century, the term diesis was used to denote the sharp, and that the microtonal interpretations are modern. > On 4 Sep 2022, at 17:44, Johannes Keller wrote: > > Thank you for these thoughts. I'm aware of the Helmholtz-Ellis notation > and decided not to use it (or any other contemporary approach to > microtonality). My thesis is that Vicentino's notation is in fact a > tabulature for his Archicembalo / Arciorgano (keyboard instruments with > up to 36 keys per octave), so they are a reference to a location on the > keyboard, not to a specific pitch (be it relative or absolute). Since > the tuning of those instruments is context-dependent it would be > confusing to define the 'meaning' of the notation in terms of exact > interval sizes. I'm happy to discuss this further in case you are > interested, but maybe we better do that off the lilypond-list. > > > Hans Åberg writes: > >>> On 2 Sep 2022, at 10:24, Johannes Keller wrote: >>> >>> I would like to use Lilypond for a critical edition of Nicola >>> Vicentino's treatise "L'antica musica" (Rome 1555). The original >>> notation uses an unconventional accidental to indicate a pitch >>> modification of a "Diesis" (ca. 1/5 of a whole tone). >> … >>> Examples of the original notation can be found here, see for example >>> fol. 12v (PDF p. 24): >>> >>> http://vmirror.imslp.org/files/imglnks/usimg/9/94/IMSLP114662-PMLP210243-lantica_musica.pdf >> >> In case you would want to translate into modern microtonal notation: >> >> The enharmonic diesis 128/125, the difference between an octave 2 and >> three Just Intonation major thirds 5/4, is actually an interval of >> relative scale degree 1, not an accidental, or an interval of relative >> scale degree 0. >> >> So this means that if this old manuscript, where the enharmonic diesis >> is written as an accidental, is translated into modern Helmholtz-Ellis >> notation, the note ends on the position one above in the staff >> notation, with a triple raised syntonic comma 81/80, combined with >> some other accidental like a flat or double flat.
Lilypond-book problem
Good morning, I have installed the version 2.22.1, wich I used for a lot of big project. A lot of times I tried to open terminal and run "lilypond-book" but without success. I already add the folder "...\usr\bin" to the environmental variabile path, in fact the command "lilypond" runs. Someone could help me? Thank you Rip_mus
custom chord
(Using LP 2.23.12) This has me flummoxed- I’m trying to reproduce a score for my own use. I have run out of ideas about reproducing the (unusual) chord name- the “4 over 2” part in particular. I’ve included a screen shot. I assume a markup column with 4 over 2, squeezed together, is part of the solution, but I would be grateful for some help. (key E maj) Thanks, Stan
Re: Alternative to Frescobaldi
I have compiled a set of step by step instructions for getting point and click going with gvim on Alma Linux. I'll start a new thread as this one is becoming longish. Andrew
Getting point and click going with gvim on Alma Linux
In response to the recent thread on alternatives to Frescobaldi on Alma
Linux I have prepared this set of instructions. I have tested this and
there are two points in addition to the notes below.
One, I am unable to get rid of the last line of the extensive status
message gvim shows at the bottom when invoked with a remote call. This
is puzzling - I am working on it.
Second, in 2.23.12 at least, there is an error, strangely only for gvim,
in libexec/lilypond-invoke editor. Line 130 is missing a comma, and must
be updated to:
"gvim": [("gvim", "--remote", "+:%(line)s:norm%(column)s",
"%(file)s")],
I have submitted a bug report request about this.
This is a variant of the document 'The Guide to getting Point and Click
going with Gvim under Ubuntu 18' I submitted to the list some years ago,
and the comments members made there may be useful to read still.
https://mail.gnu.org/archive/html/lilypond-user/2019-02/msg00536.html
These instructions are readily adaptable to other text editors that are
supported in libexec/lilypond-invoke-editor. I used Alma Linux 9.0 to
develop these notes.
Andrew
The Guide to getting Point and Click going with Gvim under Alma Linux 9
---
The NR has no detailed information about Lilypond point and click with
gvim for
Alma Linux. This note attempts to remedy that. Some information from the
NR is
copied here for ease of reference.
Requirements
Alma Linux 9.0
Document Viewer (evince)
Lilypond
gvim version 8.2 (vim-X11 package)
[assumes bash shell]
Setting the EDITOR variable
---
Lilypond uses the environment variable EDITOR to select which editor to
use to
display point and click links. For gvim, simply use the value 'gvim':
export EDITOR=gvim
Setting LYEDITOR is not required.
You can start evince from a terminal command to view a PDF. But if you
want to
click on a PDF in GNOME Nautilus to view it then just exporting this
variable
from the various bash startup files is inadequate. Gnome is started by
Xsession
in X11 before terminals and shells. Therefore it is unable to see
environment
variables set in .bashrc (or .bash_profile, etc). To resolve this matter,
recall that Xsession uses the startup file $HOME/.xsessionrc. For
environment
variables that are to be shared between GNOME applications and terminal
shells,
do the following. Create a file for variable declarations, of arbitrary
name.
Add the EDITOR setting to that file:
$ echo 'export EDITOR=gvim' > ~/.my_env_vars
Then edit ~/.xsessionrc to contain:
if [ -f ~/.my_env_vars ]; then
. ~/.my_env_vars
fi
Now also add these same lines to ~/.bashrc. Some like to use
.bash_profile or
other mechanisms, but the principle is the same. Manage any shared variables
that Nautilus and a bash shell both need in this third file. To make
this take
effect, logout and login again so that a new Xsession is started.
Installing Gvim
---
Gvim is in the following package, not a package called gvim.
# dnf install vim-X11
Configuring the GNOME 3 Desktop
---
Create the file 'lilypond-invoke-editor.desktop':
[Desktop Entry]
Version=1.0
Name=lilypond-invoke-editor
GenericName=Textedit URI handler
Comment=URI handler for textedit:
Exec=lilypond-invoke-editor %u
Terminal=false
Type=Application
MimeType=x-scheme-handler/textedit;
Categories=Editor
NoDisplay=true
Run:
$ xdg-desktop-menu install ./lilypond-invoke-editor.desktop
$ xdg-mime default lilypond-invoke-editor.desktop x-scheme-handler/textedit
Check that this works. Install the xdg-open program:
# dnf install xdg-utils
Then:
$ xdg-open textedit:///etc/os-release:1:0:0
If all is correct lilypond-invoke-editor will run and display the file.
Configuring Gvim
Not all users see this problem, but if you do, it is hard to solve if
you don't
know. On a plain new gvim install, every time you click on a lilypond grob
under the setup described here, a rather daunting status message is
shown, and
you have to press ENTER to continue, each time. This is just an example:
:if !exists('+acd')||!&acd|if haslocaldir()|cd -|lcd -|elseif getcwd()
==# '/home/andro'|cd -|endif|endif
::1898:norm3|cal foreground()|if &im|star|en|redr|f
And also 'Press ENTER or type command to continue'.
The solution to this is to change the size of the message display in
gvim. Add
the following to ~/.gvimrc:
if exists('+cmdheight') && (&ch < 2)
set ch=2
endif
You may need to set the height to 3, depending on various sizes.
[As for why some people do not see this issue, I am unclear.]
[n.b. this is from the previous issue of this document for Ubuntu 18 but the
messsage in Alma Linux persists despite this fix. I am currently working on
it.]
A Personal Preference
-
Because gvim comes by default with mouse enabled, and this is a useful
feature,
if you click i
Re: Lilypond-book problem
On Sun, Sep 4, 2022 at 9:06 AM Rip _Mus wrote: > > Good morning, > I have installed the version 2.22.1, wich I used for a lot of big project. > A lot of times I tried to open terminal and run "lilypond-book" but without > success. I already add the folder "...\usr\bin" to the environmental > variabile path, in fact the command "lilypond" runs. > Someone could help me? It would be helpful to know exactly what is going wrong. Do you get error messages? Post them. Not doing what you think it should? Tell us what it's doing and what you think it should be doing. Also, tell us the OS, is it linux? -- Knute Snortum
Re: Lilypond-book problem
Good morning, thanks for the reply! You're right, I could have added a few more details. The operating system is Windows 10. For using Lilypond on command line, I followed the instructions on the site. I added the folder "C:Program Files (x86)\LilyPond\usr\bin" to the environmental variable “Path”. I think I followed them well, as the "ilypond" command works. The other commands "lilypond-book" and "convert-ly" instead give me the following message: 'lilypond-book' is not recognized as an internal or external command What I notice is that in the folder in question there are lilypond-book and convert-ly scripts, but they are without extension (for example * .py) What do you think about? Il lun 5 set 2022, 02:13 Knute Snortum ha scritto: > On Sun, Sep 4, 2022 at 9:06 AM Rip _Mus > wrote: > > > > Good morning, > > I have installed the version 2.22.1, wich I used for a lot of big > project. > > A lot of times I tried to open terminal and run "lilypond-book" but > without success. I already add the folder "...\usr\bin" to the > environmental variabile path, in fact the command "lilypond" runs. > > Someone could help me? > > It would be helpful to know exactly what is going wrong. Do you get > error messages? Post them. Not doing what you think it should? Tell > us what it's doing and what you think it should be doing. Also, tell > us the OS, is it linux? > > -- > Knute Snortum >
