Re: [Branding Issue] Shenyu is still decleared as a project of dromara community
Thanks for the update. Sheng Wu 吴晟 Twitter, wusheng1108 Yu Xiao 于2022年6月30日周四 12:34写道： > > Hi, > > ShenYu PPMCs have good communication with the dromara community. > > Dromara Community Team clean up about Apache ShenYu links in dromara > website[1]. > > Hutool Team clean up about Apache ShenYu links in hutool website[2]. > > Sa-Token Team clean up about Apache ShenYu links in sa-Token website[3]. > > Finally, ShenYu PPMCs checked all the official websites of the > projects under the dromara community, > no other links found for Apache ShenYu（Or have been cleaned). > > [1] https://dromara.org/projects/ > [2] https://www.hutool.cn/ > [3] https://sa-token.dev33.cn/ > > -- > Best wishes! > > Yu Xiao > Apache ShenYu (Incubating) > > - > To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org > For additional commands, e-mail: general-h...@incubator.apache.org > - To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: general-h...@incubator.apache.org
Re: [Branding Issue] Shenyu is still decleared as a project of dromara community
Hi My questions have mostly to do with translations, as the source sites are predominantly in Chinese, not a language I understand. On Wed, Jun 29, 2022 at 8:38 PM Sheng Wu wrote: > Hi Shenyu and incubator > > Shenyu is going to graduate in next month, I accidentally have a > chance to review its original org, Dromara, due to some reviews for > SkyWalking PR. > > There are two things concerning me. > 1. Dromara website[1] still declare Shenyu(even with Apache prefix) on > its project page. I think this is wrong and confusing end-users. As > this project has been donated for a long time, why it is still hosted > there? > What exactly does it mean for a project to be listed on the projects page here? I didn't see any descriptive text, but nothing on the page looked like ownership. I'm not sure if Dromara is a commercial entity or not, but it's OK for a commercial company to provide support/capabilities for an Apache project. See AmazonMQ for Apache ActiveMQ as an example of this. > 2. Hutool project[2], another project hosted in dromara community, its > website declares very clearly Shenyu is a project of Dromara > community. > Again, is there a better translation/explanation of this? Is this where it's asserted that Apache ShenYu is owned by Dromara, instead of Apache? > 3. Sa-token project[3], Dromara community project. It posts Shenyu's > logo as well without Apache prefix, and it links the project to > gitee[4], which is mostly an official mirror of Shenyu. > > Could Shenyu's PMC take care of this? make sure that, Dromara is not a > big open-source community, and several people in Shenyu PMC team > actually leads this community as far as I know. > 1. From Dromara community perspective, it would keep declaring things > like this. Shenyu has been donated to the foundation. > 2. All links, especially those you could control in the Dromara > community's project, should go to the Apache website, or Apache's > GitHub repository very clearly. > There's a "Start up" button, but I'm guessing this should translate as "Getting Started". Is the intention of these Getting Started guides explaining how to run these software components within the context of Dromara? Or just how to run them in general? Mostly the reason I'm asking is because on the landing page for Dromara, it mentions the organization's purpose is "An organization dedicated to native solutions for the microservice cloud" which can be built on Apache products and if they're providing a guide on how to integrate the Apache product into their own software stack it may make sense that they're listed as an integrated component. Thanks, John > > For members of the PMC team, I hope Shenyu's PMC could take more > responsibilities to protect the ASF and project branding. This should > not be hard to find, as you are working inside Dromara community. > Unless you didn't know this is a branding, this would concern me more, > as you are going to graduate a TLP. > > > [1] https://dromara.org/projects/ > [2] https://www.hutool.cn/ > [3] https://sa-token.dev33.cn/ > [4] https://gitee.com/Apache-ShenYu/incubator-shenyu > > Sheng Wu 吴晟 > Twitter, wusheng1108 > > - > To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org > For additional commands, e-mail: general-h...@incubator.apache.org > >
Re: [Branding Issue] Shenyu is still decleared as a project of dromara community
Hi, John In a short version, they are not a legal entity. But they work like one. They worked like a virtual org, including accepting project donation, transfer projects from individual to an org, announce news from an org perspective to present this project. I believe the major reason of not being a legal entity, is that, it is hard to regisr a foundation in China. It is not about supporting projects, guide or providing local support or docs. Those are totally fine. But dromara doesn't provide that. > Dromara > 是由国内顶尖的开源项目作者共同组成的开源社区。提供包括开源网关，分布式事务，流行工具，企业级认证，微服务RPC，运维监控，Agent监控，分布式日志，调度编排等一系列开源产品、解决方案与咨询、技术支持与培训认证服务。技术栈全面开源共建、 保持社区中立，致力于为全球用户提供微服务云原生解决方案。让参与的每一位开源爱好者，体会到开源的快乐。 Dromara开源社区目前拥有10+GVP项目，总star数量超过7万，构建了上万人的开源社区，有成千上万的个人及团队在使用Dromara社区的开源项目。 This is their own statement. It clearly declare (owns projects) John D. Ament 于2022年7月3日 周日00:41写道： > Hi > > My questions have mostly to do with translations, as the source sites are > predominantly in Chinese, not a language I understand. > > On Wed, Jun 29, 2022 at 8:38 PM Sheng Wu > wrote: > > > Hi Shenyu and incubator > > > > Shenyu is going to graduate in next month, I accidentally have a > > chance to review its original org, Dromara, due to some reviews for > > SkyWalking PR. > > > > There are two things concerning me. > > 1. Dromara website[1] still declare Shenyu(even with Apache prefix) on > > its project page. I think this is wrong and confusing end-users. As > > this project has been donated for a long time, why it is still hosted > > there? > > > > > What exactly does it mean for a project to be listed on the projects page > here? I didn't see any descriptive text, but nothing on the page looked > like ownership. I'm not sure if Dromara is a commercial entity or not, but > it's OK for a commercial company to provide support/capabilities for an > Apache project. See AmazonMQ for Apache ActiveMQ as an example of this. > > > > 2. Hutool project[2], another project hosted in dromara community, its > > website declares very clearly Shenyu is a project of Dromara > > community. > > > > Again, is there a better translation/explanation of this? Is this where > it's asserted that Apache ShenYu is owned by Dromara, instead of Apache? > > > > 3. Sa-token project[3], Dromara community project. It posts Shenyu's > > logo as well without Apache prefix, and it links the project to > > gitee[4], which is mostly an official mirror of Shenyu. > > > > Could Shenyu's PMC take care of this? make sure that, Dromara is not a > > big open-source community, and several people in Shenyu PMC team > > actually leads this community as far as I know. > > 1. From Dromara community perspective, it would keep declaring things > > like this. Shenyu has been donated to the foundation. > > 2. All links, especially those you could control in the Dromara > > community's project, should go to the Apache website, or Apache's > > GitHub repository very clearly. > > > > There's a "Start up" button, but I'm guessing this should translate as > "Getting Started". Is the intention of these Getting Started guides > explaining how to run these software components within the context of > Dromara? Or just how to run them in general? > > Mostly the reason I'm asking is because on the landing page for Dromara, it > mentions the organization's purpose is "An organization dedicated to native > solutions for the microservice cloud" which can be built on Apache products > and if they're providing a guide on how to integrate the Apache product > into their own software stack it may make sense that they're listed as an > integrated component. > > Thanks, > > John > > > > > > For members of the PMC team, I hope Shenyu's PMC could take more > > responsibilities to protect the ASF and project branding. This should > > not be hard to find, as you are working inside Dromara community. > > Unless you didn't know this is a branding, this would concern me more, > > as you are going to graduate a TLP. > > > > > > [1] https://dromara.org/projects/ > > [2] https://www.hutool.cn/ > > [3] https://sa-token.dev33.cn/ > > [4] https://gitee.com/Apache-ShenYu/incubator-shenyu > > > > Sheng Wu 吴晟 > > Twitter, wusheng1108 > > > > - > > To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org > > For additional commands, e-mail: general-h...@incubator.apache.org > > > > > -- Sheng Wu 吴晟 Apache SkyWalking Apache Incubator Apache ShardingSphere, ECharts, DolphinScheduler podlings Zipkin Twitter, wusheng1108
Re: [DISCUSS] Graduate Apache MXNet (incubating) as a Top Level Project
Hi, > Thanks for the feedback. We have made some changes to the website to make > it more clear it's an Apache project, but there's further work that could > be done and I'll work with the community to get this going. While improved there could be more done here, IMO It's important to get a good example to lessen the misuse by 3rd parties. > I'm not sure what you are referring to regarding the github repo; was it > branding issues in the README.md? Yes the README.md text show on that page and it had a number of issues. Kind Regards, Justin - To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: general-h...@incubator.apache.org
Re: [Branding Issue] Shenyu is still decleared as a project of dromara community
Hi John, dromara[1] is an open source organization, and there are many developers or organizations using projects from the dromara community. Apache ShenYu was donated to ASF by dromara. So, dromara project[2] a link to the Apache ShenYu website[3]. Other projects(hutool, sa-token) under the dromara community also have a links, but they forward to a wrong address. After sheng's feedback, ShenYu PPMCs have good communication with the dromara community. these links have been cleaned up. As we all know, Apache ShenYu is copyright by ASF, as you can tell from the name. [1] https://dromara.org/ [2] https://dromara.org/projects/ [3] https://shenyu.apache.org/ Justin Mclean 于2022年7月3日周日 07:47写道： > > Hi, > > I cannot read the original but the translation seems fine to me. The only > thing that might be better worded I guess would be "Thousands of individuals > and teams are using the open source projects of the Dromara community.”? > > Kind Regards, > Justin -- -- Best wishes! Yu Xiao Apache ShenYu (Incubating) - To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: general-h...@incubator.apache.org
