RE: As sent to the neutron mailing list

[K . Shankland]

Dear All,

Erich Kisi got it right for saying that the
discussion should be on a scientific basis.
My original posting did not bring up the subject
of structure solution / refinement.  

I simply pointed out that Armel's posting to the neutron
list, deprecating the resolution of neutron 
instruments, neglected some basic evidence that
Bill, Paolo and Brian have now expanded upon.
As ever, none of Armel's replies actually acknowledge
the validity of their resolution arguments....

Do I have an axe to grind about neutrons ?  Certainly
not, as I do a lot of X-ray structure determination work.  
Coincidentally, I have an experiment starting on HRPD
tomorrow.  It's a structure determination - wish me luck ??

Best,

Kenneth