Hi Andy,
> On 3 Jan 2024, at 15:12, Andrew Newton <a...@hxr.us> wrote:
>
> Given that the TTL can be updated independently of the domain name,
> there is utility in exposing TTLs in RDAP especially if that
> information can be given with the events & links as is done with the
> DNSSEC data in RDAP. I know I have had times in the past when I needed
> to know when a TTL was last changed.
Do you think the ttl_values object needs an events array then?
To support this I would change the ttl_values object as follows:
"ttl": {
"values": {
"NS": 3600,
"DS": 60,
},
"events": [
{
"eventAction": "lastChanged",
"eventDate": "2012-07-23T05:15:47Z",
"eventActor": "registry-operator"
}
]
}
G.
>
> Here is the example from 9083:
>
> "secureDNS":
> {
>
> "zoneSigned": true,
> "delegationSigned": true,
> "maxSigLife": 604800,
> "keyData":
> [
> {
> "flags": 257,
> "protocol": 3,
> "algorithm": 8,
> "publicKey": "AwEAAa6eDzronzjEDbT...Jg1M5N rBSPkuXpdFE=",
> "events":
> [
> {
> "eventAction": "last changed",
> "eventDate": "2012-07-23T05:15:47Z"
> }
> ]
> }
> ]
> }
>
> -andy
>
> On Wed, Jan 3, 2024 at 7:17 AM Gould, James
> <jgould=40verisign....@dmarc.ietf.org> wrote:
>>
>> Gavin,
>>
>> Agreed that the base RDAP RFCs include DNS information, but in the case of
>> nameservers they are standard provisioning objects with the host EPP mapping
>> in RFC 5733 and with additional attributes. I don't believe that there is
>> value in replicating DNS information in RDAP that is not related to other
>> information (e.g., creation date, updated date, transfer date, sponsorship)
>> that may have value to the public. My recommendation is to focus management
>> of TTL in EPP with its impact on DNS and leave RDAP alone. Let's not go
>> down the slippery slope of bloating RDAP by replicating DNS information when
>> there is no perceived value.
>>
>> --
>>
>> JG
>>
>>
>>
>> James Gould
>> Fellow Engineer
>> jgo...@verisign.com
>> <applewebdata://13890C55-AAE8-4BF3-A6CE-B4BA42740803/jgo...@verisign.com>
>>
>> 703-948-3271
>> 12061 Bluemont Way
>> Reston, VA 20190
>>
>> Verisign.com
>> <https://urldefense.com/v3/__http://verisigninc.com/__;!!PtGJab4!4JeVZIu2TFksUlRg1kqU3iv7m_d4qkDyWccMxJpAmVEjAijvV3KNeAWvThRFn1pZnBMJ8BjKWVtK8DZkFyOV$
>> [verisigninc[.]com]>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>> On 1/3/24, 4:44 AM, "Gavin Brown" <gavin.br...@icann.org
>> <mailto:gavin.br...@icann.org>> wrote:
>>
>>
>> Caution: This email originated from outside the organization. Do not click
>> links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the
>> content is safe.
>>
>>
>> Hi Jim,
>>
>>
>>> On 2 Jan 2024, at 14:52, Gould, James <jgo...@verisign.com
>>> <mailto:jgo...@verisign.com>> wrote:
>>>
>>> Gavin,
>>>
>>> I question the need for a TTL RDAP extension, since the TTLs are easily
>>> assessable in DNS to the public. The management of the TTLs is provisioned
>>> in EPP via the TTL EPP extension and can be made available to the
>>> registrant by the registrar. There are examples of DNS information
>>> duplicated in RDAP, such as the DNSSEC information in RFC 9083, but I'm
>>> concerned with setting the pattern of duplicating additional DNS
>>> information with no perceived value.
>>>
>>
>>
>> RDAP domain objects contain other information that can also be obtained in
>> the DNS, such as nameservers, glue, and DS records. Evidently there is value
>> in providing this information via an alternate channel (such as to debug DNS
>> resolution issues). Providing TTL information via RDAP is consistent with
>> that approach and will also be helpful in the same scenarios.
>>
>>
>> G.
>>
>>
>>> Thanks,
>>>
>>> --
>>>
>>> JG
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> James Gould
>>> Fellow Engineer
>>> jgo...@verisign.com <mailto:jgo...@verisign.com>
>>> <applewebdata://13890C55-AAE8-4BF3-A6CE-B4BA42740803/jgo...@verisign.com
>>> <mailto:jgo...@verisign.com>>
>>>
>>> 703-948-3271
>>> 12061 Bluemont Way
>>> Reston, VA 20190
>>>
>>> Verisign.com
>>> <https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://secure-web.cisco.com/1WDhBI4oN4MzjYkRpT_wHK79lqjo81wGLL08NPt-xFPJjyn6sDCJdab6uBhbLq1pRbsZQxa7a-hYdlAzaBWt5VYvIWxi240Q1NVtJySVMdAk6lxrVxmdYoFp5-Amk_dm1Yttc1hboIe1DVDATAgzH76CZJSIYsGU358bki6jTYAJ-HrO9QUCoSHvVDsaGkNZH4C4prAkiD8kYccHVOam8VIdp2ZwNFNw-seninyVxG0YIyBT2EcGssY9T9TijHbVhDU_D6LqjNjQF7fvL3wXJCJzbyUgycb-VgNto2S094f0/https*3A*2F*2Furldefense.com*2Fv3*2F__http*3A*2F*2Fverisigninc.com*2F__;!!PtGJab4!-twuq17rqSKX-pCKHkTFhmzOXZaiQ1nbrzbWhB81AVnwvlHzeutZfLJ89yfRnjIyun6gaZT9bPAZBBwW9FcwU_pM$__;JSUlJSUlJSUl!!PtGJab4!4JeVZIu2TFksUlRg1kqU3iv7m_d4qkDyWccMxJpAmVEjAijvV3KNeAWvThRFn1pZnBMJ8BjKWVtK8COGHyZ7$
>>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]
>>> <https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://secure-web.cisco.com/1WDhBI4oN4MzjYkRpT_wHK79lqjo81wGLL08NPt-xFPJjyn6sDCJdab6uBhbLq1pRbsZQxa7a-hYdlAzaBWt5VYvIWxi240Q1NVtJySVMdAk6lxrVxmdYoFp5-Amk_dm1Yttc1hboIe1DVDATAgzH76CZJSIYsGU358bki6jTYAJ-HrO9QUCoSHvVDsaGkNZH4C4prAkiD8kYccHVOam8VIdp2ZwNFNw-seninyVxG0YIyBT2EcGssY9T9TijHbVhDU_D6LqjNjQF7fvL3wXJCJzbyUgycb-VgNto2S094f0/https*3A*2F*2Furldefense.com*2Fv3*2F__http*3A*2F*2Fverisigninc.com*2F__;!!PtGJab4!-twuq17rqSKX-pCKHkTFhmzOXZaiQ1nbrzbWhB81AVnwvlHzeutZfLJ89yfRnjIyun6gaZT9bPAZBBwW9FcwU_pM$__;JSUlJSUlJSUl!!PtGJab4!4JeVZIu2TFksUlRg1kqU3iv7m_d4qkDyWccMxJpAmVEjAijvV3KNeAWvThRFn1pZnBMJ8BjKWVtK8COGHyZ7$
>>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]> [verisigninc[.]com]>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> On 1/2/24, 9:03 AM, "regext on behalf of Gavin Brown"
>>> <regext-boun...@ietf.org <mailto:regext-boun...@ietf.org>
>>> <mailto:regext-boun...@ietf.org <mailto:regext-boun...@ietf.org>> on behalf
>>> of gavin.br...@icann.org <mailto:gavin.br...@icann.org>
>>> <mailto:gavin.br...@icann.org <mailto:gavin.br...@icann.org>>> wrote:
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> Hi all,
>>>
>>>
>>> As a complement to the EPP extension, I've just uploaded a first draft of
>>> an RDAP extension:
>>>
>>>
>>> https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://secure-web.cisco.com/1khfl7WVPWF-jsGK6Nxqwpdr3f-7zS-IMW2fy2UbmOBdDxFAso7MbjPz8VXKRq0aKCyklcAbOVTwl3-v1Sj3ZbN_hKbmdfMCh__EipHieNvm5-I92wmnx5ws0ZMai6ilhvxRlPMTmOA3Vd2dZhxiJLZ9BoFxIR6aj8fH0e2-N7pjb6j6_0WNcS4ko3gaB4oUJYXmusur7WWhL8wLPMG9Cci8s3YDe1I54CR3ivBWoKIwD206EaslQuw16Q1i6ETQERIkWmEcFnZhbnBPVHToH2TG_SWtXqcuIUHJxxvY2hss/https*3A*2F*2Furldefense.com*2Fv3*2F__https*3A*2F*2Fsecure-web.cisco.com*2F1cbpvLaxkXtiMxQku8jDm2TgXvD6OlaLPfyuDyqcKICKKvoZdwaB4a-dn4H9lpfSVFKLTxRsg8H1QbTOnAYaSDJhRJc-Nej9fgazwK0PO2MWTfIZlWiACP7SIWz5WocpqC4fi3lZlo5w7y47KB2rh2vo-xSZwzoAIEvQtKrCXy9D4MMUPMwwHI2YaYxWKqyLcsEiRiVGw0TiYcU4viI_CRckheWvm9Kdzy1y10JrHdN_aHYu06YXF606kW3ME8bi2c6QoApNmUGIZRUFmKaXxD9LTcon-6ARcRBgf_afSZas*2Fhttps__;JSUlJSUlJSUlJQ!!PtGJab4!4JeVZIu2TFksUlRg1kqU3iv7m_d4qkDyWccMxJpAmVEjAijvV3KNeAWvThRFn1pZnBMJ8BjKWVtK8AnntS74$
>>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]
>>> <https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://secure-web.cisco.com/1khfl7WVPWF-jsGK6Nxqwpdr3f-7zS-IMW2fy2UbmOBdDxFAso7MbjPz8VXKRq0aKCyklcAbOVTwl3-v1Sj3ZbN_hKbmdfMCh__EipHieNvm5-I92wmnx5ws0ZMai6ilhvxRlPMTmOA3Vd2dZhxiJLZ9BoFxIR6aj8fH0e2-N7pjb6j6_0WNcS4ko3gaB4oUJYXmusur7WWhL8wLPMG9Cci8s3YDe1I54CR3ivBWoKIwD206EaslQuw16Q1i6ETQERIkWmEcFnZhbnBPVHToH2TG_SWtXqcuIUHJxxvY2hss/https*3A*2F*2Furldefense.com*2Fv3*2F__https*3A*2F*2Fsecure-web.cisco.com*2F1cbpvLaxkXtiMxQku8jDm2TgXvD6OlaLPfyuDyqcKICKKvoZdwaB4a-dn4H9lpfSVFKLTxRsg8H1QbTOnAYaSDJhRJc-Nej9fgazwK0PO2MWTfIZlWiACP7SIWz5WocpqC4fi3lZlo5w7y47KB2rh2vo-xSZwzoAIEvQtKrCXy9D4MMUPMwwHI2YaYxWKqyLcsEiRiVGw0TiYcU4viI_CRckheWvm9Kdzy1y10JrHdN_aHYu06YXF606kW3ME8bi2c6QoApNmUGIZRUFmKaXxD9LTcon-6ARcRBgf_afSZas*2Fhttps__;JSUlJSUlJSUlJQ!!PtGJab4!4JeVZIu2TFksUlRg1kqU3iv7m_d4qkDyWccMxJpAmVEjAijvV3KNeAWvThRFn1pZnBMJ8BjKWVtK8AnntS74$
>>>
>>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]>*3A*2F*2Fdatatracker.ietf.org*2Fdoc*2Fdraft-brown-rdap-ttl-extension*2F__;JSUlJSUl!!PtGJab4!-twuq17rqSKX-pCKHkTFhmzOXZaiQ1nbrzbWhB81AVnwvlHzeutZfLJ89yfRnjIyun6gaZT9bPAZBBwW9Kx0b62K$
>>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]
>>> <https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://secure-web.cisco.com/1khfl7WVPWF-jsGK6Nxqwpdr3f-7zS-IMW2fy2UbmOBdDxFAso7MbjPz8VXKRq0aKCyklcAbOVTwl3-v1Sj3ZbN_hKbmdfMCh__EipHieNvm5-I92wmnx5ws0ZMai6ilhvxRlPMTmOA3Vd2dZhxiJLZ9BoFxIR6aj8fH0e2-N7pjb6j6_0WNcS4ko3gaB4oUJYXmusur7WWhL8wLPMG9Cci8s3YDe1I54CR3ivBWoKIwD206EaslQuw16Q1i6ETQERIkWmEcFnZhbnBPVHToH2TG_SWtXqcuIUHJxxvY2hss/https*3A*2F*2Furldefense.com*2Fv3*2F__https*3A*2F*2Fsecure-web.cisco.com*2F1cbpvLaxkXtiMxQku8jDm2TgXvD6OlaLPfyuDyqcKICKKvoZdwaB4a-dn4H9lpfSVFKLTxRsg8H1QbTOnAYaSDJhRJc-Nej9fgazwK0PO2MWTfIZlWiACP7SIWz5WocpqC4fi3lZlo5w7y47KB2rh2vo-xSZwzoAIEvQtKrCXy9D4MMUPMwwHI2YaYxWKqyLcsEiRiVGw0TiYcU4viI_CRckheWvm9Kdzy1y10JrHdN_aHYu06YXF606kW3ME8bi2c6QoApNmUGIZRUFmKaXxD9LTcon-6ARcRBgf_afSZas*2Fhttps__;JSUlJSUlJSUlJQ!!PtGJab4!4JeVZIu2TFksUlRg1kqU3iv7m_d4qkDyWccMxJpAmVEjAijvV3KNeAWvThRFn1pZnBMJ8BjKWVtK8AnntS74$
>>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]
>>> <https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://secure-web.cisco.com/1khfl7WVPWF-jsGK6Nxqwpdr3f-7zS-IMW2fy2UbmOBdDxFAso7MbjPz8VXKRq0aKCyklcAbOVTwl3-v1Sj3ZbN_hKbmdfMCh__EipHieNvm5-I92wmnx5ws0ZMai6ilhvxRlPMTmOA3Vd2dZhxiJLZ9BoFxIR6aj8fH0e2-N7pjb6j6_0WNcS4ko3gaB4oUJYXmusur7WWhL8wLPMG9Cci8s3YDe1I54CR3ivBWoKIwD206EaslQuw16Q1i6ETQERIkWmEcFnZhbnBPVHToH2TG_SWtXqcuIUHJxxvY2hss/https*3A*2F*2Furldefense.com*2Fv3*2F__https*3A*2F*2Fsecure-web.cisco.com*2F1cbpvLaxkXtiMxQku8jDm2TgXvD6OlaLPfyuDyqcKICKKvoZdwaB4a-dn4H9lpfSVFKLTxRsg8H1QbTOnAYaSDJhRJc-Nej9fgazwK0PO2MWTfIZlWiACP7SIWz5WocpqC4fi3lZlo5w7y47KB2rh2vo-xSZwzoAIEvQtKrCXy9D4MMUPMwwHI2YaYxWKqyLcsEiRiVGw0TiYcU4viI_CRckheWvm9Kdzy1y10JrHdN_aHYu06YXF606kW3ME8bi2c6QoApNmUGIZRUFmKaXxD9LTcon-6ARcRBgf_afSZas*2Fhttps__;JSUlJSUlJSUlJQ!!PtGJab4!4JeVZIu2TFksUlRg1kqU3iv7m_d4qkDyWccMxJpAmVEjAijvV3KNeAWvThRFn1pZnBMJ8BjKWVtK8AnntS74$
>>>
>>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]>*3A*2F*2Fdatatracker.ietf.org*2Fdoc*2Fdraft-brown-rdap-ttl-extension*2F__;JSUlJSUl!!PtGJab4!-twuq17rqSKX-pCKHkTFhmzOXZaiQ1nbrzbWhB81AVnwvlHzeutZfLJ89yfRnjIyun6gaZT9bPAZBBwW9Kx0b62K$
>>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]>
>>>
>>>
>>> This extension does not require the use of the EPP extension: it can be
>>> used by any RDAP server operator wishing to publish TTL information in RDAP
>>> responses.
>>>
>>>
>>> Given bandwidth constraints, I would not seek WG adoption until the EPP
>>> document is published as an RFC, but wanted to publish an early draft for
>>> review. Feedback welcome!
>>>
>>>
>>> G.
>>>
>>>
>>> --
>>> Gavin Brown
>>> Principal Engineer, Global Domains & Strategy
>>> Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN)
>>>
>>>
>>> https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://secure-web.cisco.com/1siAa4PI5puTdS9pg_-yn-oEhm9TNP92NAmmXvvKPh7y9DYQ-iMX5low002YpdSLtsE1Kxsip-HTVPkKoZTqJFqQseMgkvfdsI1G6LeLQQpnnS55xUEdUP9lFG9VjEDInRUYKdPV9LVetsRiNvNQAkFqDBPjSSnpAFifsskZTIi8vBo97p23k1fZbmi5JkbVtgRjfaqsH-IIScurgEHF8D3US8DF66MzS0u30GJ7WFZIWSBMZXyifW57ZsonoBto_N1fFTTGvwP9nohyiRJUpmWdlvAC2IdxkgtDBAghhmXw/https*3A*2F*2Furldefense.com*2Fv3*2F__https*3A*2F*2Fsecure-web.cisco.com*2F15sz32WNlSqbvdDNG-36T1VGWZDQS4oBVAEwgLa2qHna_Z6fAkHckEVLZG3WQtX7iVKHwZjjG059vJPzOG-dhenzj6zwBOavJ9GQUkhcFzy2U6eS2Uqw0_e_nmwSXS-xOWUZt_xdYJO5HKUUQ2eJ0MR2S_iWsoirMKWeFkS9EoFd3INxIzDaUC7ZsiCCNfbWpb3d-zacRh7gA53UDTnJ0u1COR0lzOoSzPVyZLZMXlUzI4hXpf8XRryhe2BjRPmMhwq5lWNw3kePM7NYMeFo-50zYlcqG094WfTDzQnR9fzI*2Fhttps__;JSUlJSUlJSUlJQ!!PtGJab4!4JeVZIu2TFksUlRg1kqU3iv7m_d4qkDyWccMxJpAmVEjAijvV3KNeAWvThRFn1pZnBMJ8BjKWVtK8EWCHkec$
>>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]
>>> <https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://secure-web.cisco.com/1siAa4PI5puTdS9pg_-yn-oEhm9TNP92NAmmXvvKPh7y9DYQ-iMX5low002YpdSLtsE1Kxsip-HTVPkKoZTqJFqQseMgkvfdsI1G6LeLQQpnnS55xUEdUP9lFG9VjEDInRUYKdPV9LVetsRiNvNQAkFqDBPjSSnpAFifsskZTIi8vBo97p23k1fZbmi5JkbVtgRjfaqsH-IIScurgEHF8D3US8DF66MzS0u30GJ7WFZIWSBMZXyifW57ZsonoBto_N1fFTTGvwP9nohyiRJUpmWdlvAC2IdxkgtDBAghhmXw/https*3A*2F*2Furldefense.com*2Fv3*2F__https*3A*2F*2Fsecure-web.cisco.com*2F15sz32WNlSqbvdDNG-36T1VGWZDQS4oBVAEwgLa2qHna_Z6fAkHckEVLZG3WQtX7iVKHwZjjG059vJPzOG-dhenzj6zwBOavJ9GQUkhcFzy2U6eS2Uqw0_e_nmwSXS-xOWUZt_xdYJO5HKUUQ2eJ0MR2S_iWsoirMKWeFkS9EoFd3INxIzDaUC7ZsiCCNfbWpb3d-zacRh7gA53UDTnJ0u1COR0lzOoSzPVyZLZMXlUzI4hXpf8XRryhe2BjRPmMhwq5lWNw3kePM7NYMeFo-50zYlcqG094WfTDzQnR9fzI*2Fhttps__;JSUlJSUlJSUlJQ!!PtGJab4!4JeVZIu2TFksUlRg1kqU3iv7m_d4qkDyWccMxJpAmVEjAijvV3KNeAWvThRFn1pZnBMJ8BjKWVtK8EWCHkec$
>>>
>>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]>*3A*2F*2Fwww.icann.org__;JSUl!!PtGJab4!-twuq17rqSKX-pCKHkTFhmzOXZaiQ1nbrzbWhB81AVnwvlHzeutZfLJ89yfRnjIyun6gaZT9bPAZBBwW9ICJXPCI$
>>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]
>>> <https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://secure-web.cisco.com/1siAa4PI5puTdS9pg_-yn-oEhm9TNP92NAmmXvvKPh7y9DYQ-iMX5low002YpdSLtsE1Kxsip-HTVPkKoZTqJFqQseMgkvfdsI1G6LeLQQpnnS55xUEdUP9lFG9VjEDInRUYKdPV9LVetsRiNvNQAkFqDBPjSSnpAFifsskZTIi8vBo97p23k1fZbmi5JkbVtgRjfaqsH-IIScurgEHF8D3US8DF66MzS0u30GJ7WFZIWSBMZXyifW57ZsonoBto_N1fFTTGvwP9nohyiRJUpmWdlvAC2IdxkgtDBAghhmXw/https*3A*2F*2Furldefense.com*2Fv3*2F__https*3A*2F*2Fsecure-web.cisco.com*2F15sz32WNlSqbvdDNG-36T1VGWZDQS4oBVAEwgLa2qHna_Z6fAkHckEVLZG3WQtX7iVKHwZjjG059vJPzOG-dhenzj6zwBOavJ9GQUkhcFzy2U6eS2Uqw0_e_nmwSXS-xOWUZt_xdYJO5HKUUQ2eJ0MR2S_iWsoirMKWeFkS9EoFd3INxIzDaUC7ZsiCCNfbWpb3d-zacRh7gA53UDTnJ0u1COR0lzOoSzPVyZLZMXlUzI4hXpf8XRryhe2BjRPmMhwq5lWNw3kePM7NYMeFo-50zYlcqG094WfTDzQnR9fzI*2Fhttps__;JSUlJSUlJSUlJQ!!PtGJab4!4JeVZIu2TFksUlRg1kqU3iv7m_d4qkDyWccMxJpAmVEjAijvV3KNeAWvThRFn1pZnBMJ8BjKWVtK8EWCHkec$
>>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]
>>> <https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://secure-web.cisco.com/1siAa4PI5puTdS9pg_-yn-oEhm9TNP92NAmmXvvKPh7y9DYQ-iMX5low002YpdSLtsE1Kxsip-HTVPkKoZTqJFqQseMgkvfdsI1G6LeLQQpnnS55xUEdUP9lFG9VjEDInRUYKdPV9LVetsRiNvNQAkFqDBPjSSnpAFifsskZTIi8vBo97p23k1fZbmi5JkbVtgRjfaqsH-IIScurgEHF8D3US8DF66MzS0u30GJ7WFZIWSBMZXyifW57ZsonoBto_N1fFTTGvwP9nohyiRJUpmWdlvAC2IdxkgtDBAghhmXw/https*3A*2F*2Furldefense.com*2Fv3*2F__https*3A*2F*2Fsecure-web.cisco.com*2F15sz32WNlSqbvdDNG-36T1VGWZDQS4oBVAEwgLa2qHna_Z6fAkHckEVLZG3WQtX7iVKHwZjjG059vJPzOG-dhenzj6zwBOavJ9GQUkhcFzy2U6eS2Uqw0_e_nmwSXS-xOWUZt_xdYJO5HKUUQ2eJ0MR2S_iWsoirMKWeFkS9EoFd3INxIzDaUC7ZsiCCNfbWpb3d-zacRh7gA53UDTnJ0u1COR0lzOoSzPVyZLZMXlUzI4hXpf8XRryhe2BjRPmMhwq5lWNw3kePM7NYMeFo-50zYlcqG094WfTDzQnR9fzI*2Fhttps__;JSUlJSUlJSUlJQ!!PtGJab4!4JeVZIu2TFksUlRg1kqU3iv7m_d4qkDyWccMxJpAmVEjAijvV3KNeAWvThRFn1pZnBMJ8BjKWVtK8EWCHkec$
>>>
>>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]>*3A*2F*2Fwww.icann.org__;JSUl!!PtGJab4!-twuq17rqSKX-pCKHkTFhmzOXZaiQ1nbrzbWhB81AVnwvlHzeutZfLJ89yfRnjIyun6gaZT9bPAZBBwW9ICJXPCI$
>>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]>
>>>
>>>
>>> _______________________________________________
>>> regext mailing list
>>> regext@ietf.org <mailto:regext@ietf.org> <mailto:regext@ietf.org
>>> <mailto:regext@ietf.org>>
>>> https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://secure-web.cisco.com/14qxqtlwjzTWan-TkcDPtaHtDs88ycWVdddAL9icbz572nzeKt1rOxSIVl3TyokXf-ZqlxDO9YDENkVhL9zoQQID9Ho5fkUfu9TR0bmb6SG2XFlyEcx7Sc4IlzeDw0Dj2UePPWckiLBdJ_Jhx5bpR4X430LdzVFx8VJ9CKeomM6PwQ_XjxRlux31-neQ3sVe5VGgy_NZ0lVc1P5qdSBNv7lLc_jBwfHJsJGxgG6pb6ubj_6b8x0vB0CC7a80P8fSnafcNBi_HQ65BrhVnh14TULnHnmtAbsl0E3J04lQoRwk/https*3A*2F*2Furldefense.com*2Fv3*2F__https*3A*2F*2Fsecure-web.cisco.com*2F1zDwYvCDqp8Pe87NHBav-VwKLD4OsQaYPVOW-QDt8_XqhAkoE0SCfc6SgIgcQhFAiYdPpEexfvZm-uUkC2yh0heIAL8jzcbiv9zv15IQnZMrwgGCMLn4E8lEelydzsbpdLXVvWFZ5KZ04pt7LRwQ54UeErCPQPqpMNHur_I8qeQIRxM7v-k93VUM9rBlpu_82laTay05HjVdCAVt0z3DYB36tn9vfn4o1dPt4_Daxaf44tEQ6uupGPq9e_HeTN1WM5Bp23i_rEMjlOxcrx-OX7KXloi4-Z4phjBY0eZ3OY2I*2Fhttps__;JSUlJSUlJSUlJQ!!PtGJab4!4JeVZIu2TFksUlRg1kqU3iv7m_d4qkDyWccMxJpAmVEjAijvV3KNeAWvThRFn1pZnBMJ8BjKWVtK8G3bj7eJ$
>>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]
>>> <https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://secure-web.cisco.com/14qxqtlwjzTWan-TkcDPtaHtDs88ycWVdddAL9icbz572nzeKt1rOxSIVl3TyokXf-ZqlxDO9YDENkVhL9zoQQID9Ho5fkUfu9TR0bmb6SG2XFlyEcx7Sc4IlzeDw0Dj2UePPWckiLBdJ_Jhx5bpR4X430LdzVFx8VJ9CKeomM6PwQ_XjxRlux31-neQ3sVe5VGgy_NZ0lVc1P5qdSBNv7lLc_jBwfHJsJGxgG6pb6ubj_6b8x0vB0CC7a80P8fSnafcNBi_HQ65BrhVnh14TULnHnmtAbsl0E3J04lQoRwk/https*3A*2F*2Furldefense.com*2Fv3*2F__https*3A*2F*2Fsecure-web.cisco.com*2F1zDwYvCDqp8Pe87NHBav-VwKLD4OsQaYPVOW-QDt8_XqhAkoE0SCfc6SgIgcQhFAiYdPpEexfvZm-uUkC2yh0heIAL8jzcbiv9zv15IQnZMrwgGCMLn4E8lEelydzsbpdLXVvWFZ5KZ04pt7LRwQ54UeErCPQPqpMNHur_I8qeQIRxM7v-k93VUM9rBlpu_82laTay05HjVdCAVt0z3DYB36tn9vfn4o1dPt4_Daxaf44tEQ6uupGPq9e_HeTN1WM5Bp23i_rEMjlOxcrx-OX7KXloi4-Z4phjBY0eZ3OY2I*2Fhttps__;JSUlJSUlJSUlJQ!!PtGJab4!4JeVZIu2TFksUlRg1kqU3iv7m_d4qkDyWccMxJpAmVEjAijvV3KNeAWvThRFn1pZnBMJ8BjKWVtK8G3bj7eJ$
>>>
>>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]>*3A*2F*2Fwww.ietf.org*2Fmailman*2Flistinfo*2Fregext__;JSUlJSUl!!PtGJab4!-twuq17rqSKX-pCKHkTFhmzOXZaiQ1nbrzbWhB81AVnwvlHzeutZfLJ89yfRnjIyun6gaZT9bPAZBBwW9PBS-cge$
>>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]
>>> <https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://secure-web.cisco.com/14qxqtlwjzTWan-TkcDPtaHtDs88ycWVdddAL9icbz572nzeKt1rOxSIVl3TyokXf-ZqlxDO9YDENkVhL9zoQQID9Ho5fkUfu9TR0bmb6SG2XFlyEcx7Sc4IlzeDw0Dj2UePPWckiLBdJ_Jhx5bpR4X430LdzVFx8VJ9CKeomM6PwQ_XjxRlux31-neQ3sVe5VGgy_NZ0lVc1P5qdSBNv7lLc_jBwfHJsJGxgG6pb6ubj_6b8x0vB0CC7a80P8fSnafcNBi_HQ65BrhVnh14TULnHnmtAbsl0E3J04lQoRwk/https*3A*2F*2Furldefense.com*2Fv3*2F__https*3A*2F*2Fsecure-web.cisco.com*2F1zDwYvCDqp8Pe87NHBav-VwKLD4OsQaYPVOW-QDt8_XqhAkoE0SCfc6SgIgcQhFAiYdPpEexfvZm-uUkC2yh0heIAL8jzcbiv9zv15IQnZMrwgGCMLn4E8lEelydzsbpdLXVvWFZ5KZ04pt7LRwQ54UeErCPQPqpMNHur_I8qeQIRxM7v-k93VUM9rBlpu_82laTay05HjVdCAVt0z3DYB36tn9vfn4o1dPt4_Daxaf44tEQ6uupGPq9e_HeTN1WM5Bp23i_rEMjlOxcrx-OX7KXloi4-Z4phjBY0eZ3OY2I*2Fhttps__;JSUlJSUlJSUlJQ!!PtGJab4!4JeVZIu2TFksUlRg1kqU3iv7m_d4qkDyWccMxJpAmVEjAijvV3KNeAWvThRFn1pZnBMJ8BjKWVtK8G3bj7eJ$
>>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]
>>> <https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://secure-web.cisco.com/14qxqtlwjzTWan-TkcDPtaHtDs88ycWVdddAL9icbz572nzeKt1rOxSIVl3TyokXf-ZqlxDO9YDENkVhL9zoQQID9Ho5fkUfu9TR0bmb6SG2XFlyEcx7Sc4IlzeDw0Dj2UePPWckiLBdJ_Jhx5bpR4X430LdzVFx8VJ9CKeomM6PwQ_XjxRlux31-neQ3sVe5VGgy_NZ0lVc1P5qdSBNv7lLc_jBwfHJsJGxgG6pb6ubj_6b8x0vB0CC7a80P8fSnafcNBi_HQ65BrhVnh14TULnHnmtAbsl0E3J04lQoRwk/https*3A*2F*2Furldefense.com*2Fv3*2F__https*3A*2F*2Fsecure-web.cisco.com*2F1zDwYvCDqp8Pe87NHBav-VwKLD4OsQaYPVOW-QDt8_XqhAkoE0SCfc6SgIgcQhFAiYdPpEexfvZm-uUkC2yh0heIAL8jzcbiv9zv15IQnZMrwgGCMLn4E8lEelydzsbpdLXVvWFZ5KZ04pt7LRwQ54UeErCPQPqpMNHur_I8qeQIRxM7v-k93VUM9rBlpu_82laTay05HjVdCAVt0z3DYB36tn9vfn4o1dPt4_Daxaf44tEQ6uupGPq9e_HeTN1WM5Bp23i_rEMjlOxcrx-OX7KXloi4-Z4phjBY0eZ3OY2I*2Fhttps__;JSUlJSUlJSUlJQ!!PtGJab4!4JeVZIu2TFksUlRg1kqU3iv7m_d4qkDyWccMxJpAmVEjAijvV3KNeAWvThRFn1pZnBMJ8BjKWVtK8G3bj7eJ$
>>>
>>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]>*3A*2F*2Fwww.ietf.org*2Fmailman*2Flistinfo*2Fregext__;JSUlJSUl!!PtGJab4!-twuq17rqSKX-pCKHkTFhmzOXZaiQ1nbrzbWhB81AVnwvlHzeutZfLJ89yfRnjIyun6gaZT9bPAZBBwW9PBS-cge$
>>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>
>>
>> --
>> Gavin Brown
>> Principal Engineer, Global Domains & Strategy
>> Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN)
>>
>>
>> https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://secure-web.cisco.com/1bNkjVh_rw1fHs_9VD4zYZRQI-05i2FYF-3A1A8mOGOU-J0Bd9f_pma_WRBfnN5iJGY1ZN4nxvM1fDtsQKBdl40sFQmiRIFyeRXFM4f6rcatJg5td-KABCOBrRt4syMiMChMBAo_0IyqusMTVaHi9euTTG_kLCqf8OHK8VF0Hiy17Jrm3LZnSnodu_c7p07z5MMmAHQRWR0MaDTk0e_V25EoKHknqztU7p1VJUlZrVLHS34ne1etatAkTxnIj7290p5F5Mt8ZeZGTfUnlcc175bMzBjiMfhql3JpA3oqh9ys/https*3A*2F*2Fwww.icann.org__;JSUl!!PtGJab4!4JeVZIu2TFksUlRg1kqU3iv7m_d4qkDyWccMxJpAmVEjAijvV3KNeAWvThRFn1pZnBMJ8BjKWVtK8EnnuyMn$
>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]
>> <https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://secure-web.cisco.com/1bNkjVh_rw1fHs_9VD4zYZRQI-05i2FYF-3A1A8mOGOU-J0Bd9f_pma_WRBfnN5iJGY1ZN4nxvM1fDtsQKBdl40sFQmiRIFyeRXFM4f6rcatJg5td-KABCOBrRt4syMiMChMBAo_0IyqusMTVaHi9euTTG_kLCqf8OHK8VF0Hiy17Jrm3LZnSnodu_c7p07z5MMmAHQRWR0MaDTk0e_V25EoKHknqztU7p1VJUlZrVLHS34ne1etatAkTxnIj7290p5F5Mt8ZeZGTfUnlcc175bMzBjiMfhql3JpA3oqh9ys/https*3A*2F*2Fwww.icann.org__;JSUl!!PtGJab4!4JeVZIu2TFksUlRg1kqU3iv7m_d4qkDyWccMxJpAmVEjAijvV3KNeAWvThRFn1pZnBMJ8BjKWVtK8EnnuyMn$
>> [secure-web[.]cisco[.]com]>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> regext mailing list
>> regext@ietf.org
>> https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/regext__;!!PtGJab4!4JeVZIu2TFksUlRg1kqU3iv7m_d4qkDyWccMxJpAmVEjAijvV3KNeAWvThRFn1pZnBMJ8BjKWVtK8L3fGvNF$
>> [ietf[.]org]
--
Gavin Brown
Principal Engineer, Global Domains & Strategy
Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN)
https://www.icann.org
_______________________________________________
regext mailing list
regext@ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/regext
