Alex ....
Thanks for posting your generalized numarray eigenvalue solution ....
It's been almost 30 years since I've looked at any characteristic equation, eigenvalue, eignevector type of processing and at this point I don't recall many of the particulars ....
Not being sure about the nature of the monic( p ) function, I implemented it as an element-wise division of each of the coefficients ....
This is correct. The aim is that p has a leading coefficient that equals 1.
Is this anywhere near the correct interpretation for monic( p ) ?
Using the version below, Python complained about the line ....
. M[ -1 , : ] = -p[ : -1 ]
Works for me. Did you perhaps use a list (type(p) == type([])) for p? Then python does not know what -p means (numeric or numarray does).
That's wrong because you don't set a slice but a single item!So, in view of you comments about slicing in you follow-up, I tried without the slicing on the right ....
. . M[ -1 , : ] = -p[ -1 ]
Old code should work. We need all coefficients but the leading coeff. So take the slice p[:-1].
The following code will run and produce results, but I'm wondering if I've totally screwed it up since the results I obtain are different from those obtained from the specific 5th order Numeric solution previously posted here ....
. from numarray import * . . import numarray.linear_algebra as LA . . def monic( this_list ) : . . m = [ ] . . last_item = this_list[ -1 ] . . for this_item in this_list : . . m.append( this_item / last_item ) . . return m
your function equals the following one:
def monic(p): return p / p[-1]
But you have to ensure that p is an array object. It does element-wise operations per default.
Remember we need future division or take float(p[-1]) or the denominator.
The degree is len(p) -1 or something smaller (some people are calling len(p) -1 a "degree bound" instead). It is smaller if p contains leading zeros which should be deleted, e.g. P(x) = x^2 + 4 x + 4 could be entered as. . . def roots( p ) : . . p = monic( p ) . . n = len( p ) # degree of polynomial
p = array([4, 4, 1, 0, 0])
which would produce a deg of 4 instead of 2.
remember to use an array or convert it on-the-fly inside your roots function:. . z = zeros( ( n , n ) ) . . M = asarray( z , typecode = 'f8' ) # typecode = c16, complex . . M[ : -1 , 1 : ] = identity( n - 1 ) . . M[ -1 , : ] = -p[ -1 ] # removed : slicing on the right . . return LA.eigenvalues( M ) . . . coeff = [ 1. , 3. , 5. , 7. , 9. ]
M[-1,:] = - asarray(p)[:-1]
. . print ' Coefficients ..' . print . print ' %s' % coeff . print . print ' Eigen Values .. ' . print . . eigen_values = roots( coeff ) . . for this_value in eigen_values : . . print ' %s' % this_value .
Any clues would be greatly appreciated ....
Hope that helps.
Alex -- http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list