In message <51fff9c5.9070...@megan.vbhcs.org>, 
Noel Jones <njo...@megan.vbhcs.org> wrote:

>No. Here, near-zero legit clients use bracketed HELO. Looks as if
>I've whitelisted 2 clients in the last ~5 years (I see one of them
>has fixed their HELO sometime since then).  That's close enough to
>zero for me.

I agree.

>My solution is to reject everyone that has a bracketed IP in the
>HELO, using a simple check_helo_access pcre map.  I don't care if a
>spambot is RFC compliant, I still don't want their mail.

We appear to be in violent agreement.

>I see zero value in testing to see if the HELO IP is forged, since
>using any IP seems to be a very strong spambot indicator.

OK.  Works for me!  I just wish that it wasn't necessary to
have to run an external PCRE to catch it, and that the
reject_non_fqdn_helo_hostname verb actually did what it's name
intutively implies, and what the documentation says it does.

[A.B.C.D] is distinctly _not_ an FQDN.


Regards,
rfg

Reply via email to