Thanks Wietse for your help!
On 02.10.2011, at 14:59, Wietse Venema wrote:
> Simeon Ott:
>> On 30.09.2011, at 19:25, Simeon Ott wrote:
>>
>>> hello,
>>>
>>> i recently configured gnarwl autoresponder on my mailserver. the
>> autoresponder works great as long as the sender doesn't use BATV.
>> otherwise the autoresponded message is not delivered to the origin
>> sender. is there a possibility to pipe another attribute then
>> ${sender} in the master.cf?
>>>
>>> here are the relevant configuration parts:
>>> master.cf:
>>> gnarwl unix - n n - - pipe flags=F
>>> user=vmail argv=/usr/bin/gnarwl -a ${user} -s ${sender}
> ...
>> Sep 30 09:22:35 ares postfix/qmgr[23383]: B00CF2C649F:
>> from=<prvs=1254408a08=send...@senderdomain.com>, size=3407, nrcpt=3 (queue
>> active)
>> Sep 30 09:22:36 ares postfix/pipe[23817]: B00CF2C649F:
>> to=<rc...@rcvdomain.com,rc...@rcvdomain.com@autoreply.example.com>,
>> relay=gnarwl, delay=0.3, delays=0.09/0.04/0/0.17, dsn=2.0.0, status=sent
>> (delivered via gnarwl service)
>
> The above shows that you provide gnarwl with the BATV-ed envelope
> sender address.
>
> You also mention that gnarwl replies to some different address but
> provide no concrete evidence.
sorry, i have to clarify this.. if you have a look at the following logfile
entries, there is some evidence
Sep 30 09:22:41 ares amavis[23081]: (23081-08) Passed CLEAN,
<rc...@rcvdomain.com> -> <p...@ares.intra.example.com>, Message-ID:
<20110930072235.ee6662c6...@ares.intra.example.com>, mail_id: Ie+WuC0MyE5S,
Hits: -1.901, size: 933, queued_as: F1F592C6101, 5101 ms
Sep 30 09:22:41 ares postfix/smtp[23791]: EE6662C64A7:
to=<p...@ares.intra.example.com>, orig_to=<prvs>,
relay=127.0.0.1[127.0.0.1]:10024, delay=5.3, delays=0.17/0/0.01/5.1, dsn=2.0.0,
status=sent (250 2.0.0 Ok, id=23081-08, from MTA([127.0.0.1]:10025): 250 2.0.0
Ok: queued as F1F592C6101)
Sep 30 09:22:41 ares postfix/qmgr[23383]: EE6662C64A7: removed
Sep 30 09:22:41 ares postfix/local[23824]: F1F592C6101:
to=<p...@ares.intra.example.com>, relay=local, delay=0.31,
delays=0.17/0.05/0/0.09, dsn=5.1.1, status=bounced (unknown user: "prvs")
these are the log entries from gnarwl after the mail is processed. GNARWL tries
to send an email to p...@ares.intra.example.com (localhost) instead of
send...@senderdomain.com. so the value is truncated at the equal sign.
>
> If the sender really looks like
> <rc...@rcvdomain.com,rc...@rcvdomain.com@autoreply.example.com>
> then that is badly malformed and that should be fixed first.
>
that was indeed a misconfiguration and I fixed it. thank you to point this out.
> To debug gnarwl, take an email message and invoke gnarwl by hand:
>
> $ gnarwl -a rcpt1@whatever -s prvs=whatever@whatever < email-message-file
>
> Then, observe what happens. If it does not reply to the sender
> that you specify, then gnarwl is mis-configured or broken.
>
> Wietse
i invoked gnarwl by hand and the same thing happend. it sends an email to
<prvs> instead of whatever@whatever. i can't change this behavior in gnarwl
that's why i was looking for another solution to pass the senders email address
instead of the batv-ed envelope from. any suggestions?
