On Thu, Oct 12, 2006 at 02:55:57PM +1000, Damian Conway wrote:
> Dave Whipp wrote:
> 
> >I'm not a great fan of this concept of "reservation" when there is no 
> >mechanism for its enforcement (and this is perl...).
> 
> What makes you assume there will be no mechanism for enforcement? The 
> standard Pod parser (of which I have a 95% complete Perl 5 implementation) 
> will complain bitterly--as in cyanide--when unknown pure-upper or 
> pure-lower block names are used.

That's going to cause pain when people using older parsers try to read
docs written for newer ones. Would a loud warning plus some best-efforts
fail-safe parsing be possible?

Tim.

> The whole point of reserving these namespaces is not to prevent users from 
> misusing them, but to ensure that when we eventually get around to using a 
> particular block name, and those same users start screaming about it, we 
> can mournfully point to the passage in the original spec and silently shake 
> our heads. ;-)
> 
> Damian

Reply via email to