Troopers before you see the movie, I have nothing but revulsion for the sequel, not yet released).
Frantisek Vlcek wrote:
Wednesday, June 16, 2004, 12:15:47 AM, Yefei wrote:
YH> Who's directing the film? It may end up the same disaster as YH> Hollywood's "Solaris" -- Average movie goers got bored by it, YH> fans of Tarkovsky's version despised it, and fans of YH> Stanislaw Lem's book hated it ( many of them felt Tarkovsky's YH> version fell short as well ). But since Will Smith is doing YH> the action, maybe average movie goers will like "I Robot".
YH> Yefei
OMG, a film version of I,Robot? I must have completely missed the news. If the Solaris analogy applies, I would dislike it, because I am a lover of Tarkovskij version. And of Stanislaw Lem. BTW, how many US PDMLers know St. Lem? Or brothers Strugackijs? These are one of the world's best SF writers, from Poland and SSSR. I am interested how well are they known outside.
More on the film versions, poor great PK Dick must be rotating in grave because of all the bad adaptations of his work into movies. Except Blade Runner, all of the other movies "hoovered" big time. It's strange that of all writers, his were adapted often, but very badly.
Best regards, Frantisek Vlcek
