On Thu, 22 Jun 2017 11:33:39 +0300, Gal Pressman wrote:
> > Is my reading correct that in case the reason is not in the
> > pddr2ethtool_table opaque binary data will be passed from the firmware
> > to user space?  Is there any particular reason to allow for this?  If
> > it's just for the rare scenario where a new error code needs to be
> > added perhaps it would be enough to dump the FW-provided message to the
> > logs?  
> 
> No binary data is passed in this patch, the monitor_opcode is simply a vendor 
> specific
> 16 bit id that is used when the reason  is not generic enough to have it's 
> own enum.

Sorry if I'm wrong, I thought this would potentially copy
ETH_GSTRING_LEN bytes to userspace:

+       if (status_message)
+               memcpy(status_message,
+                      MLX5_ADDR_OF(pddr_reg, out, 
page_data.troubleshooting_info_page.status_message),
+                      ETH_GSTRING_LEN);

I'm also still not sure why a reason would not be generic enough for
the enum, if it fits in the 16bit vendor enum... 

Reply via email to