> I recently hit a similar issue on Gentoo when I tried building Mutt > using GnuTLS (forgot to note down the versions, but I think it was Mutt > 2.2.3 and GnuTLS 3.7.8 according to Portage logs). I backed out when I > saw the "accept cert" prompt, though, since I wasn't sure how to > proceed, and instead rebuilt it with OpenSSL since it worked before (and > continues to do so today). > > Currently on Mutt 2.2.10.
I saw that ebuild update but haven't updated yet :) In any case, I solved the OpenBSD issue. Problem between keyboard and chair. Setting out to try Kevin's suggestion, I found I had set ssl_usesystemcerts=no. There was a question mark in the comment next to it and I don't remember why I changed away from the default here or what I was checking.