>One of the biggest differences between l3psycho_anal_ns and
>l3psyco_anal is exactly what you are asking about - how the estimate
>the tonality index.  One is a tweaked and cleaned up version of the
>MPEG1/2 recommendation:  the predictiictability of the energy in each
>band over several granules.  I believe it comes from thesis work
>of one of the creators of MP3.  The other is based on how peaked the
>spectrum is, and uses data just from a single granule.  Naoki wrote
>it based on data in Zweicker's book.  
                       Zweicker's book??  would you tell me the name of the book
                    or more information about the l3psycho_anal_ns    
        
>Keep in mind that all the models are very crude estimates,
>and the output should be considered as a rough guide to the noise
>shaping algorthims rather than absolute truth. 

>Mark

Reply via email to