On Mon, Feb 10, 2003 at 07:42:04PM +0100, Bernhard Praschinger wrote:
> Hallo

Hi

> If you plan HW playback

I don't.  I am transcoding to MPEG4/AVI with mencoder.

> it is not wise to crop the images to a unusal
> size.

I could understand that.

> You should use there the yuvscaler -I
> ACTIVE_widthxheight+xoffset+yoffset for setting everything outside the
> area to real black. You can also use yuvdenoise for that. 

Good to know if I use more of the mjpeg_tools (i.e. mpeg2enc, mplex,
yuv*, etc.) in the future.

> Than the mpeg encoder does not spend much bandwith for that ares. 

I am not using the mpeg2enc encoder.  It is way too slow for my
causual (encode, watch once and then delete) encoding needs.

> Lookes correct. 

Good.

> I would suggest that you encode both version one with croping and one
> with setting the active area. And see afterwards if the difference is
> with the calculation. 

Problem is that when encoding to a given bitrate, the improvement will
be a subjective visual quality (hard to quantify), not a file size
difference.  Maybe I could see if mencoder has a constant quality
setting and see if there is much of a file size difference there.

Thanks much for your input though.

b.

-- 
Brian J. Murrell

Attachment: msg00685/pgp00000.pgp
Description: PGP signature

Reply via email to