Re I'll add to that debug session that it works if i add spud to exports line and locally mount /usr/ports : [EMAIL PROTECTED]:~/ #mount -t nfs spud:/usr/ports /tmp/blah/ [EMAIL PROTECTED]:~/ #touch /tmp/blah/test
And tcpdump log on lo0 : [EMAIL PROTECTED]:~/ #tcpdump -s 65000 -i lo0 port nfsd or port sunrpc tcpdump: listening on lo0, link-type LOOP 20:13:08.734530 spud.889 > spud.nfsd: xid 0x74c57a86 124 access fh 33,252/664798720 0002 20:13:08.734847 spud.nfsd > spud.889: xid 0x74c57a86 reply ok 120 access c 0002 20:13:08.734982 spud.889 > spud.nfsd: xid 0x74c57aba 120 getattr fh 33,252/3064333824 20:13:08.735117 spud.nfsd > spud.889: xid 0x74c57aba reply ok 112 getattr REG 644 ids 1000/9 sz 0x0 20:13:08.735230 spud.889 > spud.nfsd: xid 0x74c57ae3 128 lookup fh 33,252/664798720 "test" 20:13:08.735396 spud.nfsd > spud.889: xid 0x74c57ae3 reply ok 236 lookup fh 33,252/3064333824 20:13:08.735684 spud.889 > spud.nfsd: xid 0x74c57bbb 124 access fh 33,252/664798720 0002 20:13:08.735859 spud.nfsd > spud.889: xid 0x74c57bbb reply ok 120 access c 0002 20:13:08.736009 spud.889 > spud.nfsd: xid 0x74c57bd4 148 setattr fh 33,252/3064333824 20:13:08.736208 spud.nfsd > spud.889: xid 0x74c57bd4 reply ok 144 setattr Landry On 10/19/07, Landry Breuil <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > On 10/19/07, Jan Stary <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > > > Again: set WRKOBJDIR on the client side and you don't need > > > > > to be writing in the remotely mounted tree at all. > > > > > I'm already setting WRKOBJDIR outside nfs-dir, the problem is more for > > > /usr/ports/packages .. i'd like it to be shared too, to install the > > > same package on various sparc64 for example. And this dir needs to be > > > root-writable, as it uses sudo.. > > > > You also need to set DISTDIR and PKGREPOSITORYBASE > > - see examples in the FAQ. > > I now several workarounds and tweaks like this exists :) I just want > to understand why this setup doesn't work. > > > > I'd put it outside nfs if i don't find a solution, but btw i'm more > > > interested in understanding why -maproot=root doesn't work in my case > > > > Send your complete server:/etc/exports, client:/etc/fstab, > > verbose log of server:mountd, server:nfsd, and a full (-s 65000) tcpdump > > of the communication. > > server is spud, client for tests is renton (10.246.200.10). > server:/etc/exports: > /nfsroot/net_sparc64 -ro allison > /nfsroot/open_sparc64 -ro swanney > /usr/ports -maproot=0:0 renton swanney lizzy > > client fstab: > spud:/usr/ports /usr/ports nfs rw,nosuid 0 0 > > mountd -d output: > Got line /nfsroot/net_sparc64 -ro allison > Making new ep fs=0x0,0xfc214a5e > doing opt -ro allison > got host allison > exporting /nfsroot/net_sparc64 > Got line /nfsroot/open_sparc64 -ro swanney > Found ep fs=0x0,0xfc214a5e > doing opt -ro swanney > got host swanney.fr.homeunix.org > exporting /nfsroot/open_sparc64 > Got line /usr/ports -maproot=0:0 renton swanney lizzy > Found ep fs=0x0,0xfc214a5e > doing opt -maproot=0:0 renton swanney lizzy > got host renton.fr.homeunix.org > got host swanney.fr.homeunix.org > got host lizzy.fr.homeunix.org > exporting /usr/ports > exporting /usr/ports > exporting /usr/ports > unexporting / / > Getting mount list. > Here we go. > Got mount request from 10.246.200.10 > rpcpath: /usr/ports > Mount successful for /usr/ports by 10.246.200.10. > > (here i've ran sudo mount /usr/ports on the client) > > renton:~/ $ls -ld /usr/ports > drwxrwxr-x 47 root wsrc 1024 Oct 19 19:12 /usr/ports (same on > client and server) > renton:~/ $id > uid=1000(landry) gid=1000(landry) groups=1000(landry), 0(wheel), 9(wsrc) > renton:~/ $touch /usr/ports/test > renton:~/ > > Here i have tcpdump output (same for server and client) for this > sucessful file creation : > 19:56:29.030254 renton.695 > spud.nfsd: xid 0xbb06905b (NFSv3) 112 > lookup fh 33,252/664798720 "test" > 19:56:29.030771 spud.nfsd > renton.695: xid 0xbb06905b reply ok 116 > lookup ERROR: No such file or directory > 19:56:29.030843 renton.695 > spud.nfsd: xid 0xbb069116 (NFSv3) 112 > lookup fh 33,252/664798720 "test" > 19:56:29.031099 spud.nfsd > renton.695: xid 0xbb069116 reply ok 116 > lookup ERROR: No such file or directory > 19:56:29.031131 renton.695 > spud.nfsd: xid 0xbb069170 (NFSv3) 144 > create fh 33,252/664798720 "test" > 19:56:29.033013 spud.nfsd > renton.695: xid 0xbb069170 reply ok 268 > create fh 33,252/3064333824 > 19:56:29.033097 renton.695 > spud.nfsd: xid 0xbb069202 (NFSv3) 104 > getattr fh 33,252/3064333824 > 19:56:29.033363 spud.nfsd > renton.695: xid 0xbb069202 reply ok 112 > getattr REG 644 ids 1000/9 sz 0x0 > > Now i try to update attrs, it fails : > renton:~/ $sudo touch /usr/ports/test > touch: /usr/ports/test: Permission denied > > 19:57:52.066602 renton.695 > spud.nfsd: xid 0xbb0692d4 (NFSv3) 128 > lookup fh 33,252/664798720 "test" > 19:57:52.067288 spud.nfsd > renton.695: xid 0xbb0692d4 reply ok 236 > lookup fh 33,252/3064333824 > 19:57:52.067380 renton.695 > spud.nfsd: xid 0xbb069303 (NFSv3) 124 > access fh 33,252/664798720 0002 > 19:57:52.067688 spud.nfsd > renton.695: xid 0xbb069303 reply ok 120 > access c 0002 > 19:57:52.067725 renton.695 > spud.nfsd: xid 0xbb0693f4 (NFSv3) 148 > setattr fh 33,252/3064333824 > 19:57:52.068015 spud.nfsd > renton.695: xid 0xbb0693f4 reply ok 144 > setattr ERROR: Permission denied > 19:57:52.068051 renton.695 > spud.nfsd: xid 0xbb06947e (NFSv3) 124 > access fh 33,252/664798720 0002 > 19:57:52.068299 spud.nfsd > renton.695: xid 0xbb06947e reply ok 120 > access c 0002 > 19:57:52.068326 renton.695 > spud.nfsd: xid 0xbb06952e (NFSv3) 148 > setattr fh 33,252/3064333824 > 19:57:52.068605 spud.nfsd > renton.695: xid 0xbb06952e reply ok 144 > setattr ERROR: Permission denied > > Now i try to create another file, it fails : > renton:~/ $sudo touch /usr/ports/test2 > touch: /usr/ports/test2: Permission denied > > 19:58:24.546477 renton.695 > spud.nfsd: xid 0xbb0695bf (NFSv3) 132 > lookup fh 33,252/664798720 "test2" > 19:58:24.547033 spud.nfsd > renton.695: xid 0xbb0695bf reply ok 116 > lookup ERROR: No such file or directory > 19:58:24.547166 renton.695 > spud.nfsd: xid 0xbb06960d (NFSv3) 132 > lookup fh 33,252/664798720 "test2" > 19:58:24.547430 spud.nfsd > renton.695: xid 0xbb06960d reply ok 116 > lookup ERROR: No such file or directory > 19:58:24.547475 renton.695 > spud.nfsd: xid 0xbb069643 (NFSv3) 164 > create fh 33,252/664798720 "test2" > 19:58:24.547777 spud.nfsd > renton.695: xid 0xbb069643 reply ok 60 > create ERROR: Permission denied > > (btw, as root on server i can touch/create files in /usr/ports) > I suppose next step is ktrace'ing nfsd, as it has no -d/debug/verbose > option... i really have no idea what doesn't work. Tried with > maproot=root and =0 too. > > Thanks for any help. > > Landry
