... On port 37 (time, UDP). 

If timedc from a NetBSD host attempts clockdiff with an OpenBSD host
(same ethernet, no firewalling involved), sending from a privileged
port, OpenBSD (inetd, I presume) does not respond.  If the UDP packet
originates from an unprivileged port (say 63,xxx or 19,xxx), then
all is happy.  Why is OpenBSD set up this way?  I recall a philosophical
security issue for this, and would like to refresh my memory, so that
I might offer an explanation to some people at Net.  I can't seem to
find a discussion anywhere in /usr/share/man/*.

They are taking the position that it is upside down to require an
unprivileged source port.  What are the issues?

Thanks,

Dave

Reply via email to