On Thu, Jul 08, 2021 at 12:18:09PM -0400, Brian Brombacher wrote:
[..]

> Are you changing the default TCPKeepAlive setting?  It defaults to yes.  It 
> exists as options in sshd_ and ssh_config.  Additionally, ClientAliveInterval 
> and ServerAliveInterval might be handy.  A sysctl also exists to turn TCP 
> keep alive on for all connections by default.
> 

I didn't change that setting but I have this on pod's sshd_config:

#TCPKeepAlive yes

> Not sure it???ll help.  Does your download crawl to a halt, then after a 
> period of time, you get the FIN?


So what I'm doing is 'scp pod:Backup/*gz .' to the local directory on arda
(local host).

In the tcpdump the packets go by fairly rapidly in fact there is a lot of
packets before the FP (fin packet) even makes it through to arda (because there
is at least a dozen packets in flight).

One note here:  I applied the IPSEC to escape any in-band attacks, however when
I did that last week, the very first time I tried to scp my backups the
connection did indeed crawl to a halt.  It was just sitting there.  I worried
back then that someone spoofed WIN 0's into the IPSEC'ed stream somehow but
I applied anti-spoof rules on IPSEC so that can't happen and the fear was
probably unfounded in retrospect.  I still don't have an explanation for myself
for that though.  Perhaps it was the missing scrub to lower the MTU on enc0
which isn't adjustable?   Anyhow last week then I did manage to download the
4 GB of backups, but doing so this week proved to not work.


> (Note: I don???t have any Hetzner hosts and I???m just guessing based on my 
> experience with Azure)
> 
> -Brian

Thanks.  I looked over my firewall rules on enc0 a little and did notice I have
a scrub rule that changes the mss to 1240 I'm not sure tough if that will
cause this behaviour.  It wasn't used anyhow when I just did the plain scp
without wrapping IPSEC around it, and then it still FIN'ed and subsequent
RST'.

Best Regards,
-peter

Reply via email to