FYI: I'm modifying ubuntu-keyboard to fill out the input shape (which is how the client API calls it [1]) of its surface so that qtmir/unity8 knows where in ubuntu-keyboard's fullscreen surface is the graphical on-screen kbd being drawn (in order to replace the hack we currently have, which uses a separate socket to exchange this info). It works well.

[1] - https://bugs.launchpad.net/mir/+bug/1588967

On 06/06/2016 08:14, Daniel van Vugt wrote:
Best I can recall, that feature is incomplete. But also the vast majority of apps and toolkits don't care that it's still incomplete.

What we want is for it to be an actual region (union of rectangles) and a client API to set the input region of a surface. So for example, a non-rectangular surface may specify its shape and clicks that are outside of that shape (but still inside the surface rectangle) pass through to the surface below.


On 04/06/16 13:38, Alan Griffiths wrote:
On 03/06/16 21:17, Daniel d'Andrada wrote:
Hi,

I was working under the assumption that, in mir::scene::Surface,
input_bounds() was the bounding box of the input region [1]. But it
was always returning the full surface size no matter what.

Then, checking implementation, I saw that it simply returns the
surface size. Is that the correct and intended definition of
input_bounds (there's no documentation on it, so its definition
follows from the implementation itself)? Wouldn't it be more useful
and accurate if it were the bounding box I thought it was? Or is it
just a bad by-product of having scene::Surface inherit from
input::Surface, making input_bounds() a redundant property of the former.

- Daniel

[1] by the way, why there's no input_region() getter in
scene::Surface? qtmir would sure make good use of it. Now it has to
rely on shell::WindowManager::modify_surface to get this information.


Yes, this is broken. (In several ways.)

Last time I discussed it with duflu I came away with the opinion that
fixing it wasn't trivial as there are competing, incompatible
assumptions around the code.




--
Mir-devel mailing list
Mir-devel@lists.ubuntu.com
Modify settings or unsubscribe at: 
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/mir-devel

Reply via email to