On 2015-10-09, Liviu Andronic wrote:

...

>>> Besides checking everything that may go wrong, remember that the
>>> second most important part of the job is to say "no"! And that's not
>>> the easiest part.

>> Out of curiosity, what French typography dictates for a punctuation sign
>> after a double quote? Shouldn't it be inside the quotes? 8-)

> Isn't this an English peculiarity? I can't remember seeing
> end-of-phrase punctuation marks within quotes in any other language...

At least in German, the rule is: put the punctuation where it belongs --
either the quote or the enclosing sentence.

* The Duden says: "A complete sencentce is enclosed including the
  punctuation."

* Partial sentences or single words are quoted without punctuation.

In the above example, it depends on the exact meaning:

* to say "No!" -- shout/speak/write the imperative "No!".

* to say "no"!  -- reject something (but maybe in this case the quotes
  should be better left out alltogether).
  
  
Günter  

Reply via email to