Allan Rae wrote:
> >
> > Open:              Collapse "Open" and "Import". Open according to file
> >                    extension: .lyx, .tex, .txt, .nw, .doc are opened as
> >                    you expect.
> >                    Does .txt input need a "as lines/as paragraph" popup?
> 
>                         If the file named doesn't exist the proceed as for
>                         "New from Template" using the filename supplied
>                         so long as it's a lyx file.
> P.S.  Still confused?

Hmm, is "Open an non-existing LyX file" then identical to "New from template"?

If so, the only difference is that "Open" you will result in a valid filename
for your new LyX document prior to choosing the template (whereas
"New from template" would assume an "invalid" filename, that forces a "Save as"
when saving). Right?

I believe that "Open" should ONLY allow you to open an existing file,
whether that's lyx, latex, text, noweb or doc (extension sensitive!).
Don't make a "New from templates" also a hidden feature of "Open".

A lot of confusion starts when menu items do more than what you expect.
So:
   let "Open" do just an *open*
   let "New from template" and "New" start a document from scratch.

Then menu items hardly need more explanation. It does what is says, not more
not less!

Regards,

Rob.

Reply via email to