These patches look good to me, but it would be nice to get rid of uglies like:

> +/*
> + * Written by Dave Hansen <dave.han...@intel.com>
> + *
> + * run like this:
> + pid=31390; BDIR="$(cat /proc/$pid/smaps | grep -B1 2097152 | head -1 | awk 
> -F- '{print $1}')"; ./mpx-dig $pid 0x$BDIR
> +
> +NOTE:
> + assumes that the only 2097152-kb VMA is the bounds dir
> + */

(weird vertical alignment)

> +long nr_incore(void *ptr, unsigned long size_bytes)
> +{
> +     int i;
> +     long ret = 0;
> +     long vec_len = size_bytes / PAGE_SIZE;
> +     unsigned char *vec = malloc(vec_len);
> +     if (!vec)

(missing newline)

> +             mpx_dig_abort();
> +
> +     int incore_ret = mincore(ptr, size_bytes, vec);

(weird non-kernel-style definition.)

> +char buf[100];
> +int open_proc(int pid, char *file)

(missing newline)

> +{
> +     int fd;
> +     sprintf(&buf[0], "/proc/%d/%s", pid, file);

(ditto, also unsafe looking sprintf())

> +void __dave_abort(int line)
> +{
> +     perror("abort");
> +     printf("abort @ %d\n", line);
> +     mpx_dig_abort();
> +}
> +#define dave_mpx_dig_abort() __dave_abort(__LINE__);

maybe s/dave// ? ;-)

> +//This mincore stuff works, but the bounds tables are not
> +//sparse enough to make it worthwhile

bad comment style.

> +     unsigned char incore_vec[MPX_BOUNDS_TABLE_SIZE_BYTES/ PAGE_SIZE];
> +     int incore_ret = mincore(bt_buf, MPX_BOUNDS_TABLE_SIZE_BYTES, 
> &incore_vec[0]);

stray whitespace.

> +             //if (!incore_vec[page_nr])
> +             //      continue;

ugly.

> +             if (this_bt_entry_for_vaddr > 0x00007fffffffffffUL) {
> +                     this_bt_entry_for_vaddr |= 0xffff800000000000;
> +             }

unnecessary curly braces.

> +             // Each bounds directory entry controls 1MB of
> +             // virtual address space.  This variable is the
> +             // virtual address in the process of the
> +             // beginning of the area controlled by this
> +             // bounds_dir.

ugly.

> +             unsigned long bd_for_vaddr = bd_index * (1UL<<20);
> +             //printf("%s() at bd index: %lx for vaddr: %lx\n", __func__, 
> bd_index, bd_for_vaddr);
> +             //printf("dir entry[%4ld @ %p]\n", bd_index, 
> bounds_dir_global+i);

Ditto.

> +             int nr_entries = dump_table(bounds_dir_entry, bd_for_vaddr, 
> bounds_dir_global+bd_offset_bytes+i);
> +             total_entries += nr_entries;
> +             continue;
> +             printf("dir entry[%4ld @ %p]: 0x%lx %6d entries total this buf: 
> %7d bd_for_vaddrs: 0x%lx -> 0x%lx\n",
> +                             bd_index, buf+i,
> +                             bounds_dir_entry, nr_entries, total_entries, 
> bd_for_vaddr, bd_for_vaddr + (1UL<<20));

hm?

> +     // there shouldn't practically be short reads of /proc/$pid/mem

> +
> +     incore_ret = mincore(dig_bounds_dir_ptr, buffer_size_bytes, &vec[0]);

stray space.

> +             //if (this_entries)
> +             //      printf("entries this loop: %d total: %d (bufs skipped: 
> %d)\n", this_entries, total_entries, bufs_skipped);

You know the drill!

> +#ifdef MPX_DIG_REMOTE
> +int main(int argc, char **argv)
> +{
> +     int err;
> +        char *c;

hm...

etc. - ad nauseum. Would be nice to tidy this all up a bit.

Thanks,

        Ingo

Reply via email to