Xavier Scheuer: > On 31 December 2012 15:22, Karl Hammar <k...@aspodata.se> wrote: > > How do I merge Ds and Ms below so it will behave as if I wrote the > > dynamics together with the notes? > > > > (snip) > > > > If I use << \Ms \\ \Ds >> the dynamics will come out to the left > > (compared to the in the notes version), probably since the dynamics > > are centered under the notes and a skip doesn't have a width (?). > > Hi, > > << \Ms \Ds >> % without the "\\" > will behave as if you wrote the dynamics together with the notes.
Same thing, the dynamics are centered under the left edge of the notes.
The attached example shows:
for \new Dynamics:
the forte is squeesed between note and lyrics
for within the notes:
p and f does not line up well
for << \Mb \Ds >>:
the p and f are displaced to the left
for the markup version:
s_\markup{ \dynamic f }\> becomes above each other
I think I like the \new Dynamics version best if I could get the same
space above and under the dynamics as for the within notes case.
Note, the hairpin ends in the same place.
> Which version are you using?
$ lilypond --version
GNU LilyPond 2.17.10
Switched today from
$ lilypond --version
GNU LilyPond 2.15.39
> There used to be an issue that made dynamics attached to spacer rests
> come out to the left (compared to attached directly to the notes),
> but it has been fixed in LilyPond version 2.15.24.
> https://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=1861
That example worked without a problem.
> Since current stable version is 2.16.1, you should not have
> encountered this issue, unless you are using a very old version.
Regards,
/Karl Hammar
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Aspö Data
Lilla Aspö 148
S-742 94 Östhammar
Sweden
+46 173 140 57
a.pdf
Description: a.pdf
\version "2.17.10"
Ls = \lyricmode { Kyr -- i -- e }
La = \lyricmode { Kyr -- i -- e }
Lt = \lyricmode { Kyr -- i -- e }
Lb = \lyricmode { Kyr -- i -- e }
Ds = {
s4\p s\f\> s\! s
}
Ms = \context Voice = Vs \relative a' {
a4 b c d^\markup{ "with \\new Dynamics" } |
}
Ma = \context Voice = Va \relative a' {
a4\p b\f\> c\! d^\markup{ "within the notes" } |
}
Mt = \context Voice = Vt \relative a' {
a4 b c d^\markup{ "as << \Mt \Ds >>" } |
}
Db = {
s4_\markup{ \dynamic p } s_\markup{ \dynamic f}\> s\! s
}
Mb = \context Voice = Vb \relative a' {
a4 b c d^\markup{ "with the forte as a markup" } |
}
\score {
\new ChoirStaff <<
\new Staff { \Ms }
\new Dynamics = Ds \Ds
\lyricsto Vs \context Lyrics = Ls { \Ls }
\new Staff { \Ma }
\lyricsto Va \context Lyrics = La { \La }
\new Staff << \Mt \Ds >>
\lyricsto Vt \context Lyrics = Lt { \Lt }
\new Staff << \Mb \Db >>
\lyricsto Vt \context Lyrics = Lb { \Lb }
>>
}
_______________________________________________ lilypond-user mailing list lilypond-user@gnu.org https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-user
