2012/11/7 Olivier Biot <olivier.b...@gmail.com>: > On Tue, Nov 6, 2012 at 12:01 AM, Thomas Morley > <thomasmorle...@googlemail.com> wrote: >> 2012/11/5 Olivier Biot <olivier.b...@gmail.com>: >>> Dear all, >>> >>> I think I just found a Lilypond bug. >>> >>> The following snippet with fingerings does only show one "open string" >>> fingering while TWO have been written. The order of _ and ^ play no >>> role in this bug. >>> >>> Expected behavior: both "\open" fingerings are displayed, one above >>> and one below selected note. > > [ ...] > >> Hi Olivier, >> >> I'm not sure that it is a bug. >> >> script-init.ly shows: >> open = #(make-articulation "open") >> >> So \open is an articulation (not a fingering). >> I think a note can be articulated only once in the same manner, so I'd >> _expect_ that one setting is skipped. >> >> BTW, \open is printed different compared to fingerings. I'd prefer to use >> d8_0^0 > > Thank you for this input Thomas. For a cellist I see no distinction > between using "finger 0" and using an open string (\open). Technically > the "\open" macro is an articulation, but I do not know if it should > be seen as an articulation rather than as a fingering. Same with > "\flageolet" and "\thumb"... > > Right now I replaced "\open" with "0" in that score snippet so I could > render both fingerings on the score. > > This of course raises the question whether there should be a specific > subset of articulations that should behave more like fingerings (I'm > thinking \open, \flageolet and \thumb here). Unless I'm completely > wrong. > >> P.S. >> If you think you've detected a bug, you should send it to the bug-list: >> http://lilypond.org/doc/v2.17/Documentation/web/bug-reports.html >> On the user-list it might get lost. > > Thank you for pointing me to the bug list! > > Best regards, > > Olivier
Hi again, I stumbled across http://lsr.dsi.unimi.it/LSR/Item?id=631 { <c'_\open^\open> } works. Cheers, Harm _______________________________________________ lilypond-user mailing list lilypond-user@gnu.org https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-user
