>>> There's a problem there, too, in that the default value depends on
>>> the grob.
>>>
>>> In MeasureSpanner, the default value is (staff-bar . staff-bar)
>>>
>>> In PercentRepeat, it's (break-alignment . staff-bar)
>>
>> I don't see a problem here.
> 
> You can't talk about *the* default value, because it's not unique;
> you can only talk about *a* default value.

The improved version of a grob description I showed neither uses a
definite nor an indefinite article for that.  I think it should be
clear that on a page that describes grob 'foo', the displayed default
value is for exactly this grob.  Don't you agree?

>> Maybe a grob description on the page showing the available default
>> properties for `MeasureSpanner` could be displayed [...]
> 
> The default values seem to be set in grobs, not interfaces, so as an
> alternative, how about something like ...
> 
>  ‘spacing-pair’ (pair)
>       A pair of alignment symbols which set an object's spacing
>       relative to its left and right ‘BreakAlignment’s.
> 
>       interface(s):
>            centered-spanner-interface, multi-measure-interface
>       default value in grob(s):
>            CenteredBarNumber: [none]
>            MeasureCounter: '(break-alignment . break-alignment)
>            MultiMeasureRest: '(break-alignment . break-alignment)
>            PercentRepeat: '(break-alignment . staff-bar)
> 
> (with the appropriate links added)

*If* we had a page that showed all grob properties, then we could do
that.  However, right now we repeat a property description for each
and every grob if it gets used.  Assuming a description page for grob
'foo' I see no additional value in having default values displayed for
other grobs; this just makes the description unnecessarily longer.

>> A user can also very easily define new commands that better fits
>> the intended purpose, for example,
>>
>> ```
>> strummingHandFinger = \rightHandFinger
>> ```
> 
> Yes. Also, I guess not as many left-handed players are upset about
> this as I thought.

I'm left-handed by myself (but playing the piano), and I don't feel
offended :-) By the way, AFAIK you are the very first person that ever
mentioned this issue.


    Werner

Reply via email to