Hi, I have a question about using a custom engraver to modify how grace notes appear when LilyPond’s new string bending is applied to them. This is the first custom engraver I’ve attempted to write, so I think I’ve overlooked something rather basic. The repository for the engraver is at https://github.com/nwhetsell/lilypond-bending-additions, and the current engraver is at
https://github.com/nwhetsell/lilypond-bending-additions/blob/0bbfdaa9a76bef10c4b23cc97b1edede8fde2f2a/bending-additions.ily Conceptually, I’m trying to do three things: 1. If a string bend starts on a grace note, don’t reduce the size of the fret number in a TabStaff. 2. If, in addition, the bent grace note is a pre-bend, put the notehead in parentheses, and don’t draw ledger lines, flags, or stems. 3. If a string bend ends on a grace note, don’t draw the notehead, ledger lines, accidentals, flags, or stems (don’t draw anything, basically). Bearing in mind that there’s a lot about writing engravers that I don’t know, where I think I’m having difficulty is determining whether a note is a grace note. In short, I’m getting a notehead grob using an acknowledger and then checking the value of its ly:moment-grace <https://lilypond.org/doc/v2.24/Documentation/internals/scheme-functions#index-ly_003amoment_002dgrace> in the engraver’s stop-translation-timestep method. However, this doesn’t work directly. In stop-translation-timestep, the moment of a notehead created in that timestep appears to always be null. As workaround, I’m saving the notehead and then getting its moment in the next call to stop-translation-timestep, at which point the notehead’s moment is no longer null. The issue here is that there are some properties that appear to only have an effect when they’re applied to a notehead in the same timestep in which it’s created. For example, setting no-ledgers to #t has no affect when applied to noteheads from a previous timestep. There’s some simplified code that attempts to illustrate this below. Is there another way for a custom engraver to determine whether a note is a grace note? Thanks in advance! Nate \version "2.24.0" #(define (Grace_reporting_engraver context) (let ( (current-note-head '()) (previous-note-head '())) (make-engraver (acknowledgers ((note-head-interface engraver grob source-engraver) (set! current-note-head grob))) ((stop-translation-timestep engraver) (if (not (null? current-note-head)) (let ( (moment (grob::when current-note-head))) (if (not (null? moment)) (if (not (eq? (ly:moment-grace moment) 0)) (begin (newline)(display "==> current-note-head is for a grace note"))) (begin (newline)(display "==> current-note-head has null moment"))))) (if (not (null? previous-note-head)) (let ( (moment (grob::when previous-note-head))) (if (not (null? moment)) (if (not (eq? (ly:moment-grace moment) 0)) (begin (newline)(display "==> previous-note-head is for a grace note"))) (begin (newline)(display "==> previous-note-head has null moment"))))) (set! previous-note-head current-note-head) (set! current-note-head '()))))) { \new Voice \with { \consists #Grace_reporting_engraver } { \grace c' \grace d' \grace e' } } #(define (Current_note_ledger_hider context) (let ( (current-note-head '())) (make-engraver (acknowledgers ((note-head-interface engraver grob source-engraver) (set! current-note-head grob))) ((stop-translation-timestep engraver) (if (not (null? current-note-head)) (ly:grob-set-property! current-note-head 'no-ledgers #t)))))) { \new Voice \with { \consists #Current_note_ledger_hider } { \grace c''' \grace c''' } } #(define (Previous_note_ledger_hider context) (let ( (current-note-head '()) (previous-note-head '())) (make-engraver (acknowledgers ((note-head-interface engraver grob source-engraver) (set! current-note-head grob))) ((stop-translation-timestep engraver) (if (not (null? previous-note-head)) (ly:grob-set-property! previous-note-head 'no-ledgers #t)) (set! previous-note-head current-note-head) (set! current-note-head '()))))) { \new Voice \with { \consists #Previous_note_ledger_hider } { \grace c''' \grace c''' } }
