Hello Craig and Netters,

   Having closely followed the list for almost 7 years now it's been  
a huge learning experience. One thing that seems to be working well  
for a majority of the flying KRs is simplicity. Craig, your project  
seems quite ambitious and would certainly be a work of art when  
completed; however would it really be worth hundreds of hours of  
cosmetic work and possibly corrupting flight characteristics? To try  
and make a KR something it is not seems counter-productive but that  
is just the opinion of a dreaming simpleton. It seems like if you  
were to take a Spitfire replica design and make mods to the canopy  
and such you would wind up with a much more true to shape bird that  
would not have flight parameters compromised. The wing shape, tail  
shape, and so forth are much more similar with a SMS Mk 26 than a KR.  
I think you would have more luck morphing from a different airframe  
and most importantly still have a safe bird to fly.

  Seeing as one of the best performing KRs out there is still in  
primer cosmetics would be one of the last things to be of concern. If  
you go adding all that weight (5 blade prop for instance) or any  
retract system you're going to have a plane that performs poorly and  
as a result exhibit much less of a safety margin. Should an accident  
occur as a result of such not only will all the work have been for  
naught, it will have been much more expensive.

  When you look at any of the nice KRs out there to corrupt them from  
their form would almost be a sacrilege. Look at Richard Shirley's  
KR1, Troy Pettiway's KR2, Jeff Scott's KR2, Larry, Joe, Mark J., Mark  
L.  KR2s (and I know I'm leaving out a lot of folks) and there is a  
purity to those planes. They are in and of themselves awesome  
examples of functional art.

OK, returning to lurk mode. Fly safe everyone.

Bart Ferguson
Houston, TX


On Oct 17, 2010, at 6:26 PM, Craig Williams wrote:

> My Bad.  I opened my big mouth without running the numbers first.   
> Here are the
> #'s

Reply via email to