Am 04.12.24 um 02:50 schrieb Justin Zobel:
On 4/12/24 01:52, Lucy wrote:
Dear KDE Team,
As a long-time user and supporter of KDE, I am writing to express my
concern regarding the recent decision to set double-click as the
default interaction for opening files and folders in KDE Plasma 6.
While I understand the intention of aligning KDE with what may be
perceived as mainstream user expectations, this decision seems at odds
with the core principles that have always defined KDE: freedom,
configurability, and serving the unique needs of its loyal community.
Linux users have chosen this platform not because it mimics other
operating systems, but precisely because it offers an environment that
prioritizes user choice and individuality. Setting double-click as the
default behavior may cater to users transitioning from Windows or
macOS, but it disregards the preferences of KDE’s long-established
user base, many of whom have embraced single-click as a hallmark of
KDE’s innovative user experience.
This change, though seemingly minor, sends an unfortunate message:
that KDE may be prioritizing conformity over its long-standing
tradition of empowering users to shape their environment as they see
fit. Instead of adopting defaults that resemble other platforms, KDE
should continue to showcase its unique strengths—flexibility,
customization, and a commitment to open innovation.
I urge the KDE team to reconsider this default setting and engage with
the community on how such changes impact the user experience. By
preserving the spirit of user-centric design, KDE will not only retain
its dedicated supporters but also stand as a beacon of choice in the
increasingly homogenized world of technology.
Thank you for your attention, and I hope this feedback helps guide
future decisions.
Sincerely,
Lucy. S & Linux Community
Hi Lucy,
As you've mentioned this is only a default settings. KDE users are still
empowered to make their own choices in the Settings. This settings is
even considered important enough to be on the Quick Settings page which
is the first to appear.
Justin
Hi all,
it's nice to see this appearing on the settings front page! I must admit
it's quite some time since I checked that, I used single-click mode
since ever, and it has been a long time since I set up a new machine
without taking ~ with me ...
But I still fully agree with Lucy's reasoning and I also think we should
have "our" single-click mode set as the default. Especially when it's so
easy to change.
My experience with "real" end-users (do we have any though?!) is that
defaults are not changed. People accept what they are being served. And
I fully agree that the one-click mode is an outstandig feature of our
desktop, that makes a big difference to Windows or macOS. We should push
this and present us a bit more confident here.
Cheers, Tobias
