https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=499825
--- Comment #29 from Christian (Fuchs) <k...@fuchsnet.ch> --- (In reply to Nate Graham from comment #28) > If it makes you feel better, it can be CLOSED INTENTIONAL rather than CLOSED > NOT A BUG. > > Ultimately the code path you're talking about has almost no impact here, and > I think people are focusing on it unnecessarily. I disagree for multiple reasons. First of all for consistency (e.g. offering the option in other places since we noticed that users care a lot about it, and we stood on quite some feet there), but also because while it is possible to create your own or use a different icon theme, without that option you are forced to delete icons every time symbolic ones are (re)-added and either have to workaround that on every update, or create a forked set and thus no longer get other updates. Long story short: while some people might have preferences or even opinions on it, it's imho an entirely valid wish, and thus closing it with closed intentional (or not a bug) is imho bad practice and could be done on just 95% of our feature requests if we wanted. Especially as this imho should be a broader discussion iff we want to set on something final, and I saw none of it happen in the usual places. > The specific issue that Aleksey wants such a setting to work around is > actually a bug in the Oxygen icon theme; apparently it claims to have > symbolic icons, but they're "half colorful, half symbolic" and Aleksey > considers them ugly. That's fair. But it's something that needs to be > resolved by either changing the icons in the Oxygen icon theme to not be > ugly and fake symbolic, or to use a different icon theme. Only half-true, the reason why this feature request was created was my feature request about the opposite, which got implemented in 6.3 (well, it's broken, but different problem), I'd know, since I follwed the discussion since then. The problem in oxygen was brought up way after, and is imho just an excuse to close this one. -- You are receiving this mail because: You are watching all bug changes.
