Hello Pierre,

Am Samstag, den 22.03.2008, 13:17 +0100 schrieb Pierre Joye:
[...]
> Read: Code validation (like in pre commit rules), is one common usage.

Where? I've just never seen any project that does XML validation on XML
templates as a pre-commit rule.

> Think about xml being XML data or HTML. Nothing prevents one to write
> valid (x)html in a valid xml format.

Again: there is no point in validating at a pre-interpreted XML files
(if they contain interpretable code).

> And again this exact example was a proof to a *wrong* claim, it has to
> be extended to be applicable to a real life context. 

Making the example longer (aka "applicable to a real life context"?)
would not change the common characteristics. My claim is, that a
pre-interpreted XML file with PHP instructions can't be reliably
validated anyway, so their is no reason bothering with it. 

> This small but obvious example is not a real life context but only
> (and only!) the proof that Stan's claim was wrong, period.

I'm not sure to which claim you are referring, but I'm not Stas advocate
so this might be true :)

cu, Lars

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Dies ist ein digital signierter Nachrichtenteil

Reply via email to