On Mar 25, 2013, at 12:24 PM, Joe Abley <jab...@hopcount.ca> wrote:
>
> My habit is to have the document source (and rendered copy) open on my screen
> as I read and digest comments. If I make a change to the document following
> someone's comment, I add them to the Acknowledgements section (and update the
> change history section that I keep in a disposable appendix). The additional
> effort required to do these small things is not great; I feel that the value
> of such work is non-zero.
Joe -
I believe that your habit is likely the common practice; I've certainly
done the same when editing. Note that this does not result in everyone
making a comment being included, e.g. if four folks point out something
to be fixed, then I'm likely to include the one who actually suggests text,
or otherwise provides the best summary of the problem. In my experience,
reviewers have been quite happy just to see their suggestions acted on,
but apparently that is no longer sufficient in some contexts.
/John
Disclaimers: My views alone, although Acknowledgements given to the members
of the "ietf" mailing list for their substantial contributions.
