El 2019-10-12 03:32, Ricardo Wurmus escribió: > Jens Mølgaard <j...@zete.tk> writes: > >> Ricardo Wurmus <rek...@elephly.net> writes: >> >>> Please keep the language here civil. We don’t need more anger on our >>> lists. If you feel frustrated, please take some time off email [...] >> >> I agree about the language, but I have to say that I share ng0's >> sentiment, and I'd like to weigh in for some more moderation of these >> topics. > > You and I agree. We have already pointed out to Jean Louis that this > behaviour is unacceptable on our mailing lists. Posts from > non-subscribers are also moderated since a few days. > >> Personally, I think putting some people in a moderation queue is a good >> idea. > > This is the next step. > > Thank you for your support!
So we are officially on a censored list, where the ones in power of the administration and their followers control the others' speech because there is not an agreement on netiquette on others' terms but on the terms they impose. That is the usual way oppressive regimes justify their proceedings. It is not a way that kind people proceed. If there is a real intention of safety and kind communication, I suggest to avoid censorship, even if the best communication procedures follow the netiquette you propose (and to which I agree upon, except for the censorship which you chose to call moderation). I suggest to try and keep civility by showing and suggesting civility instead of imposing it. Imposing it would be absolutely non-civil. Regarding that the "civil" people abandon the list, I suggest to propose those who agree with the censors to create a list where they invite only the ones that think such moderation is acceptable. When a person has entered that list and has accepted and later refused to accept those terms, it is also their right to change their mind. All freedom in history has been gained that way. So that way you are not censoring anyone, you are just sharing you personal space with the ones which agree with you. But if you would do that, you would be alone unless you find someone that has no opinion and is only obeying you. At some point, there is always imposition if there is censorship.
